1, advantages:
Five-stroke input method: fast
Pinyin input method: simple and easy to use
2. Disadvantages:
Wubi input method: difficult to use
Pinyin input method: The speed is not as fast as Wu Bi input method.
Personal tests illustrate the problem.
3. Both test the same item (3 times)
Pinyin input method: 40-60 (long-term Pinyin users are about 50-60 (of course, some tentacle monsters will be more, and here is only for ordinary users to compare), and I have used this for about a month within 50).
Wubi input method: 70-90 (I stopped using Wubi for more than a month)
4. Summarize their problems and reasons.
Pinyin:
Pinyin has a fatal disadvantage, that is, homophones are repeated, especially when 1-2 words are used, which is easy to shift, especially when one word is used, which is also the reason why Pinyin can't get up quickly.
Five strokes:
The only difficulty is that the roots are difficult to learn, and it is difficult to cut off the roots in the application process.
5. Personal experience
There are many people on the Internet who say that the speed of Pinyin can exceed that of Wubi input method, which is based on blind self-confidence.
Why do you say that?
Let's talk about why pinyin can catch up with the five-stroke input method in speed.
Because pinyin was not as smart as cloud computing before, some phrases could not be automatically included, so the previous pinyin could not keep up with half of the five-stroke input method.
So can Pinyin be compared with Wu Bi input method now?
The answer is of course: no!
Why is this? Because many people have a misunderstanding, they think that many words are the same when they see that they are typing quickly.
In fact, the spelling rate of pinyin is very high, so isn't it that the longer you use it, the faster you play it?
No, it really isn't!
At this point, someone will definitely question me. Pinyin is full of intelligence, and the more phrases you remember, the more you remember. How can it not be faster and faster?
For this cloud intelligence, it really helps pinyin to improve its speed, which is understandable, but you should not forget one of the most important issues.
Homophonic problem! Focus! Focus! Focus!
If you use that phrase too much, it will take up the previous phrase, which will lead you to keep choosing words. Tell me, isn't this the bottleneck?
Then let's look at another problem, the problem of short spelling and full spelling. Many people think that many pinyin words can be short spelled, but when you use them, you will find that you basically have to spell them all.
Then, spell a phrase with at least 4 letters and at most 10 letters. What does this data show?
Sometimes you use Pinyin to type two words, and Wubi input method can type twice as many words as you, so Wubi is faster than Pinyin.
Let's talk about the problem of long entries first.
Some people will say that Pinyin can write a paragraph, and you can type it directly by simply spelling it. Simple spelling requires only the first letter.
Then I'll tell you, you can type a big four-letter paragraph or do pinyin, but you can't do more. Because of homophones, if you occupy a position, it will affect the position of other pinyin. If you don't believe in yourself, you can try.
Let's talk about intelligent word formation first. There are five strokes, so it is not a patent of pinyin.
Besides, Wu Bi's phrases are faster and more convenient than Pinyin.
Finally, I want to say that Pinyin is still not as good as Wu Bi. If you want to type fast, Wu Bi is better.