Zhang Yuhuan was acquitted, Zhang Yuhuan's defense lawyer and other related words frequently rushed to the hot search list. The parties have been wronged for 26 years and missed the best years of their lives; While praising Wang Fei's supreme merit, his persistence saved Zhang Yuhuan from the mire and brought new life and dawn. I also paid attention to Weibo, a lawyer in Faye Wong. After this incident, I can see messages praising and crying for help every day. But on second thought, does Zhang Canyuhuan's acquittal show that he is completely innocent? The answer is no.
He was acquitted for the following reasons.
0 1, from the procedural point of view, Zhang Yuhuan appealed at the first judgment of the first instance. The final judgment, as a defendant in a criminal case, has no defense lawyer. Anyone with legal knowledge knows that in China, the defendant in a criminal case must have a defense lawyer. Those who have not hired defense lawyers also have legal aid lawyers. It can be seen that it has not been implemented in this case. As a result, not allowing the defendant to speak will inevitably lead to unjust, false and wrong cases.
02, from the evidence, just because the hemp rope and sack organizations extracted similar ingredients from Zhang Yuhuan's clothes, they were convicted, but there was no evidence, tools and motivation at the first scene, so it was very far-fetched to assume that Zhang Yuhuan was the murderer. Moreover, according to China's laws, a relatively complete chain of evidence must be formed, and the case cannot be investigated by the police's intuition or judged by the judge's knowledge on paper. We should take facts as the basis and law as the criterion.
03. From the aspect of extorting a confession by torture, Zhang Yuhuan pointed out many times that his two confessions were made under the condition of being bitten by a German shepherd and all kinds of abuse, and the statements were inconsistent, so it was impossible to restore the scene. Even so, the procuratorate made a guilty verdict. Can't help but be touching. If there is less violence and coercion and more listening to the true disclosure of the parties, similar cases will be less and less.
Legally speaking, no one in the west can incriminate himself, although it is not clear in China? No doubt? However, in judicial practice, it is being gradually implemented, and there has been a saying that no one can be guilty without the judgment of the people's court. All of the above, from the evidence to the confession, have great flaws, which is why Zhang Yuhuan can't be convicted in the end. But if he is found not guilty, it will prove that he is completely innocent. This is totally two different ways of thinking. Generally speaking, it is possible that Zhang Yuhuan really killed someone. We should have enough evidence. Without evidence, we can't be convicted and acquitted.
The above is only the author's opinion. Welcome to add comments in the message area.