In fact, judging from the judgments of the first and second trials of this case, the man's behavior does not belong to justifiable defense, but he thinks that the man's defense is excessive, and according to the results of the first and second trials, the man's act of hitting his brother-in-law with a spade belongs to intentional S-person, so the result of the first trial of this case is that the man committed the crime of intentional S-person, sentenced to six years in prison and deprived of political rights for two years; The result of the second trial was that the man committed the crime of intentional S and was sentenced to 3 years in prison. However, many people actually disapprove of this judgment, because the man's purpose was to protect his sister, and her life was seriously threatened at that time. Therefore, from the legal definition, the man's behavior conforms to the definition of justifiable defense. So many people think that the man's behavior belongs to self-defense. Later, after the media paid attention to this matter, Baoding Intermediate People's Court tried the case again. What was the verdict of the first instance and the second instance? Unclear facts, insufficient evidence and wrong application of law? Then the judgment of the first instance and the second instance was directly revoked. Therefore, from this attitude, the man's behavior belongs to self-defense.
Next, I will explain the legal definition of justifiable defense to you coldly, that is, taking defensive actions against X and S people, robbery, QJ, kidnapping and other violent crimes that seriously endanger personal safety, resulting in unlawful infringement of personal casualties, is not excessive defense and does not bear criminal responsibility. Therefore, from the legal definition, the man's behavior occurred when his brother-in-law stabbed his sister with a knife, which fully conforms to the legal definition of justifiable defense, so the man's behavior belongs to justifiable defense, not intentionally. Finally, I want to say coldly that the law is fair. If you feel that the court's decision is unfair, you can continue to appeal, and you must believe that fairness will always come!