The transaction of sky-high price calligraphy and painting reveals the mystery of the identity of Dongguan appraisal expert
The sky-high price of 87.36 million calligraphy and painting is self-hyping by buying low and selling high?
What has attracted as much attention as the two authentic paintings of "Liu Yan" is the "Picture of Han and Cypresses in Songyang" written by Emperor Qianlong. The seller first bought it for 170,000 yuan, but regretted it when he learned that it had been sold at a sky-high price of 8.736 million yuan. After appraisal by an appraisal expert, the buyer filed a lawsuit in court. For various reasons, the case reached a deadlock.
In September 2009, Zhengzhou citizen Zhu Yun took the family heirloom "Songyang Han Botu" to participate in the treasure appraisal activity of Henan TV Station. Zhu Yun said that appraisal expert Liu Yanyi took a fancy to the painting and invited him to the hotel for an interview in the evening. "He told me at his residence that this painting was worth 30,000 yuan even if it was not an authentic work by Qianlong." Liu Yanyi also said, if you find someone to buy this painting, you can ask for an extra thirty to fifty thousand. Zhu Yun then gave up participating in the treasure appraisal and agreed with Liu Yanyi to find someone to buy the painting.
The reporting materials submitted by Zhu Yun to the Zhengzhou Intermediate People's Court showed that on October 21 of the same year, Liu Yanyi brought a buyer named Cheng, and the transaction was finally completed for 170,000 yuan.
In June 2011, while watching TV, Zhu Yun discovered that the "Songyang Han Bo Tu" painted by Emperor Qianlong and sold by him had been auctioned by Beijing Poly Company for 87.36 million yuan in December 2010. "At this time, I realized that the value of this painting was much more than 170,000 yuan, and I realized that I had been defrauded by Liu Yanyi and Cheng." In August last year, he filed a civil lawsuit in court.
According to the phone number provided by Zhu Yun, the reporter contacted Zhao Yuzhang, the presiding judge of the First Civil Division of the Zhengzhou Intermediate People's Court, who was responsible for the case. He said that the person involved, Zhu Yun, has applied to be transferred to the public security organ for investigation.
What is the real value of the "Songyang Han Bo Tu" mentioned by Zhu Yun? Liu Yanyi, an appraisal expert who participated in the entire painting purchase process, explained to reporters that the transaction price was recognized by both parties and "they have nothing to do with my transaction." (Source: Southern Metropolis Daily Southern Metropolis Daily Nandu Net
Liu Yanyi particularly emphasized that in the current art market, there are several paintings with the same theme of "Songyang Han Cypresses". This one The painting can be judged to be a famous pen. As for the two parties, he neither said it was authentic nor that it was a fake. "It is not easy to draw conclusions."
As for the "Songyang Han Cypress Painting", he did not say it was authentic or fake. The sky-high price was sold at a well-known auction. Liu Yanyi explained, "It was actually the buyer Cheng who spent money to hype it up and sold it to himself."
The reporter then contacted the buyer Cheng. , asked if the price of 87.36 million yuan for Zhu Yun's painting was self-promotion? He said: "This has nothing to do with you." He hung up the phone in a hurry.
In April this year, Zhengzhou. The Municipal Intermediate People's Court made interrogation records for Liu Yanyi and the buyer Cheng. Liu Yanyi said that in response to the judge's inquiry, the auction company claimed that the painting was "bought by the client."
Liu Yanjia: Three years ago. Before, I asked a lawyer to call him and ask him to stop stealing my information.
Liu Yanyi: The other party did not find me 100%.
Liu Yanjia: (He stole my resume). "Easy to do, persuasive"
Liu Yanyi: I have served as an appraisal expert on TV treasure appraisal programs in Beijing, Henan, Shandong and other places, and I am quite influential. The two people's online information overlaps. It's self-evident which one is more advantageous.