Qian Renfeng's nephew Qian Lunrong said that since 2002, Qian Renfeng's relatives have been looking for the procuratorate, and the procuratorate asked them to find the court; They went to the court and told them to go to the public security department and Zhaotong Public Security Law. Then they went to Zhaotong, and Zhaotong told them to go to Qiaojia. Always coming and going like this.
Suspicious criminal motive
There is something wrong with Qian Renfeng's motivation: what kind of hatred a female teacher urges her to poison her students and two or three-year-old children. This is a big question;
The police's assessment is questionable.
The same pot of rice is eaten by more than a dozen children. As a result, 3 children were poisoned, 1 person died and 2 people were injured. The rest of the students are safe and sound. There is a clear difference between poisoning and not poisoning. If this pot of rice is poisonous, it is impossible that some are poisoned and some are asymptomatic. So I thought there was something wrong with the police appraisal at that time.
Suspense of trial
Judicial procedure loophole
After consulting the file, Yang Zhu found that the judicial authorities' identification of the case from the motive to the process of committing the crime all came from Qian Renfeng's own inconsistent confession. The police found that Qian Renfeng's fingerprints were not found on the physical evidence. According to the interrogation record, Qian Renfeng was interrogated for 12 hours from "knowing nothing" to his first confession.
The cause of the crime is not true.
In the subsequent police interrogation, Qian Renfeng's information about the motive, time and method of committing the crime was inconsistent. The reason for the crime was "because I felt that Zhu Mei (the director) ignored me and yelled at me that day. I wanted to make those babies sick, and Zhu Mei couldn't." Later, "someone is going to die." When the investigators asked about the relationship between kindergarten director Zhu Mei and Qian Renfeng, they got the answer: "The relationship is not bad, there is no contradiction". Qian Renfeng was identified as the murderer when Zhu Mei put forward another important suspect who was not examined.
Suspected of dereliction of duty in handling cases
Yang Zhu: Zhu Mei has made it clear in the police record that the son who hates her most is the deputy political commissar of the Public Security Bureau at that time, and this person is most likely to retaliate! It may be inextricably linked, so that more than 20 police officers handling the case did not investigate the primary suspect in this case; And everyone's contradictions point to Qian Renfeng. This is the biggest doubt I said! If the police can't even explain this, what makes your court judge Qian Renfeng!
Re-call for the new normal
On July 20 13, Qian Renfeng's complaint came into the sight of the Yunnan Provincial Procuratorate, which seized all the files of Qian Renfeng's poisoning case and formally put it on file for review. However, from 20 13 to 20 14, the investigation progressed slowly.
A reporter tried to interview Gao Jiefeng, deputy director of the Appeal Department of Yunnan Provincial Procuratorate, who was in charge of the case. He entrusted his colleagues to decline the interview:
Colleague Gao Jiefeng: We are still coordinating this case with the court and the provincial public security department. The result of questioning depends on the high court, and retrial is not a matter for the high court.
Earlier, Gao Jiefeng told the media: "The case is being processed, mainly because it is too old and some evidence needs to be re-identified."
A reporter contacted the appeal review court of the Yunnan Provincial High Court, and the other party said that they did not understand the specific circumstances of the case.
We should focus on the trial
Many problems arise because they rely on the evidence obtained by the police unilaterally, so judges must change their ideas and focus on trial rather than investigation.
Although the investigation by the procuratorial organs has made slow progress, the correction of the wrong case of Hugue Gilletu and the review of the Nie Shubin case have made Qian Jia see hope and believe that the law will give Qian Renfeng a statement.
Qian Renfeng, a smart family from Yunnan, has been in prison for more than ten years. Qian Renfeng and his family have been on the way to complain.
Qian Renfeng was sentenced to life imprisonment for a poisoning case. In this case, testimony and evidence are full of contradictions. It is unacceptable that Qian Renfeng was sentenced to life imprisonment, but the real poisoner has been at large.
On April 9, 20 10, several lawyers from a law firm in Yunnan Province went to the Second Women's Prison in Yunnan Province for legal aid. Zhu Hanzhong, director of the law firm, still remembers the cases discovered by ordinary rights protection.
"Seeing us is like seeing the savior. I knelt down and cried and shouted that I was embarrassed. The supervisor can't stop it. " In his view, "Qian Renfeng's case is very surprising." From the psychological point of view of prisoners, it is rare for them to cry grievances after eight years in prison. "In a case like this, if it is determined to be premeditated, it is the clearest to do it yourself. If you are still screaming after sitting in prison for 8 years, at least you need to put a question mark on the case. "
Lawyer Yang Zhu, who went to legal aid, took over Qian Renfeng's poisoning complaint. After many times of communication with Qian Renfeng and contact with Qian Fu and his relatives and friends in Qiaojia, on September 7, 20 10, Qian Renfeng and his father entrusted Yang Zhu to investigate and collect evidence on the poisoning case in that year and applied for retrial.
As a public welfare legal aid, Yang Zhu did not charge any fees. Coincidentally, on the day when Yang Zhu and Qian Renfeng signed the entrustment agreement, it has been eight years since Qian Renfeng was convicted in the first instance.
After talking with Qian Renfeng and consulting the archives of that year, Yang Zhu and Zhu Hanzhong strengthened their judgment. In their view, at least it is certain that the evidence collected by the police and accepted by the court in the poisoning case is almost untenable.
In a letter to Yang Zhu, Qian Renfeng said: "Ignorance of the law in those years led to such a result today, which brought a heavy blow to the families who were not rich." In the previous meeting, Yang Zhu also talked with Qian Renfeng about his concerns. In the face of poisoning cases, it is difficult to apply for retrial. It's even harder to be innocent.
The first difficulty is money. According to Yang Zhu's calculation, if the Yunnan Provincial High Court rejects the application, it may need to go to Beijing to reflect the situation, and the round-trip fare is expensive.
According to the old criminal procedure law at that time, Qian Renfeng would not be released from prison until at least 20 15 years if nothing happened. "But it may take longer because she has been complaining."
In the end, Yang Zhu decided to join hands with Qian Renfeng's cousins Qian Renzuo and Wang Jingui, as well as his nephew Qian Lunrong and others, which contributed to Qian Renfeng's appeal. So far, I am on my way to apply for a retrial for Qian Renfeng.
20 1 1, Yang Zhu submitted a retrial application to the Yunnan Higher People's Court on behalf of Qian Renfeng. 201116 The Higher People's Court believes that the evidence identified in the original trial has been cross-examined and authenticated by the court of the original trial, and the evidence is objective and true, which can be mutually verified and form a chain of evidence. The original judgment was accurate, the sentencing was appropriate, and the trial procedure was legal. Qian Renfeng's application for retrial was rejected. But it was not until April of 20 14 that Yang Zhu received this rejection.
Since then, relatives of Yang Zhu and Qian Renfeng have submitted complaint materials to the Yunnan Provincial Political and Legal Committee, Yunnan Provincial Public Security Department and other relevant departments, but all of them have fallen into the sea. During the period of 20 14, Yang Zhu and Wang Jingui went to Beijing to reflect the situation. As of 20 14, 12.26, there was no result.