Huaer's Xi Shua was identified as plagiarism by experts.
China Sichuan News Network (March 2006-13)
The long-standing unresolved case of "Flowers" suspected of plagiarism has made new progress this week. A few days ago, Chen Qi, a musician, was invited by Beijing New Century Weekly, and after appraisal, he came to the conclusion that the four songs of Huaer Band, Xi Shuan, The Best Pet in the World, Fairy Tales, Life and Death Field and Star Opera, were indeed plagiarized.
Chen Qi, formerly known as Chen Qi, once taught in Guangxi Art College and worked as a composer and pianist in the Second Artillery Art Troupe. Now he is the music director of China International Cultural Exchange Publishing House, and is known as the first performer of "Free Piano Music in the New Century" in China. Jiang Hong, cultural editor of New Century Weekly, expressed 100% affirmation to Chen Qi. He said that as a pianist and an expert in classical music, Chen Qi is an outsider who has little to do with pop music, so that he can make a fair judgment. But at the same time, the professionalism of serious music gives him authority.
It is reported that the appraisal report consists of three parts. First, Wall is suspected of plagiarizing the soundtrack of the relevant paragraphs of the track; Second, it is suspected of plagiarizing the music score of the corresponding paragraph of the track; The third is the analysis and summary of music technology. Chen Qi said: "They are not imitations or coincidences at all, but plagiarism, and similar paragraphs have long exceeded the eight sections limited by relevant copyright laws. From the rhythm, speed, style and even harmony of music, imitation can only imitate one of them, and it is impossible for all parts to be consistent. When the flower band uses the music, they always choose the most brilliant paragraphs and only change those parts that do not affect the overall effect of the music. For example, Xi Shua, the melody is basically the same, except that a few notes are added in front. What kind of imitation is this? It's also gilding the lily. This can't be a coincidence of creation. "
For such appraisal results, Jiang Hong said that they only paid attention to hot issues and played a role in attracting jade, because the appraisal results did not have legal effect, so that everyone could hear the voices of all parties, but more importantly, they should attract the attention of relevant institutions and people.
Yesterday, the reporter telephoned the staff of EMI about the appraisal results. As soon as she heard that it was the appraisal result, she immediately said that she would not accept any interviews, but she also said that she could not represent the company. Finally, she told reporters that Hua Er would not be interviewed now.
Related links
Specific appraisal results of 4 songs
Swallows in Jin Jianmo vs the best pets in the world.
Both paragraphs are minor, and the number of bars is exactly the same, which is a complete structure of 8 bars. The former is 100 beats per minute, and the latter is 108 beats per minute, which belongs to a faster type of song. In the bass voice, the two are similar, starting from the dominant voice. Their singing styles and intonation are also very similar, and there is no difference in music.
K3' s Back in Time vs Fairy Tale Life and Death Love
These two pieces of music have exactly the same structure, the speed is 96 times per minute, and the mode belongs to the same mode. At medium speed, the music feels light and lively, and this piece of music occupies an important position at the beginning of the song. In the deconstruction of musical form, the repetition of the two parts has the characteristics of Rondo, but the two parts end in different ways, the former ends in the dominant chord and the latter ends in the main chord.
Pappy's "K2G Running to You" vs "Hush"
These two paragraphs are basically the same, except that the latter has made some changes in some unimportant places. For example, the latter added two sounds at the beginning, which turned the music that had entered from the second beat into the first beat; In the seventh bar, the latter changed the long note in front and extended two bars at the end.
Grihariville's Call vs Planet Opera
As a chorus part of the song, this passage has become the climax of the song for many times. Both of them are characterized by unique harmony minor, accompanied by the alternation of big and small sounds. Although there are some differences between the semi-termination and termination of two paragraphs, these changes in termination cannot change the musicality of the whole paragraph. The 6-degree jump is the core content of this passage, and the change of termination has no effect on it.