What are the nutritional components of Bedolin milk powder?

Infant assessment

Trace back to the source and teach you how to choose safe and good milk powder for your baby!

"The first brand of domestic milk powder" and "the leader of domestic milk powder"-these were the labels of Beinmei.

However, in 2006 and 2007, * * * lost/kloc-0.80 billion yuan, and the stock market faced the risk of delisting, which made many people feel pass the parcel: Is milk powder worth buying with such a big loss?

Idiot dad once wrote an article about Beinmei's embarrassing history. So aside from the company's performance level, what is the quality of Beinmei milk powder? What's the difference between different series? Which series is more worth buying?

In this issue, the fifth bomb of domestic milk powder evaluation was launched.

Routine reminder: If you don't want to see detailed data analysis, you can directly look at the following summary, or pull it to the end of the article to see the total score and summary; If you want to know more details and make more targeted choices, please read the full text patiently.

If you want to see a series of published comments on foreign brands and domestic brands of milk powder, you can enter keywords in the background or view them in historical articles.

Scoring summary

The most expensive red love is average, while Arnaudas, which is relatively cheap, scores higher.

1 ranking: ① Innoda ② green love ③ classic optimization.

Two rankings: ① Arnaudas ② Green Love ③ Ai Jia and Red Love.

Three rankings: ① Arnaudas and green love ② Red love.

1, number of version segments

version

Beinmei's milk powder series is the largest in domestic milk powder. Official website shows that 18 products are on sale, and the formula of 17 has been registered.

Stupid dad can't understand, doesn't the Regulations on the Registration and Management of Formula Milk Powder say that an enterprise is only allowed to register 9 product formulas of 3 formula series in principle? How can you live so much?

In this evaluation of Beinmei milk powder, only 9 series sold in Tmall and JD.COM official flagship stores were selected, including: Ai Jia, Love of Green, Love of Red, Anoda, Ai Jing, Classic Optimization, Tongxiang, Zhenyou and Bedolin.

Among them, Zhenyou and Bedolin are a series of products jointly launched by Beinmei and two other maternal and child brands, Dr. Yu Ying and nuefeld.

The latest product drawings of each series of milk powder are as follows:

↑

count

In terms of the number of segments, Ai Jing, Classic Optimization and Sharing are divided into 1-4 segments, while other series are divided into 1-3 segments, and their applicable ages are very conventional.

2. Comparison between milk source and milk-based raw materials

Milk source

↑

Summary:

① The milk sources of Green Love and Red Love come from Ireland and are imported from original Irish cans; Anoda's milk comes from New Zealand and is imported from New Zealand original cans.

The two places belong to the "golden milk source belt" of 40-50 degrees north and south latitude, and the pasture environment, dairy breed, dairy feeding management and raw milk safety control are better and stricter.

② Other milk sources come from Heilongjiang, China, and are from China. Although the milk source is not comparable to Ireland and New Zealand, it is superior to other domestic milk sources.

Milk-based material

↑

In terms of raw materials, only the whole model of Anoda uses fresh skim milk, and most of the other series of raw materials are added with milk powder. The freshness of raw milk will be better than that of milk powder.

In addition, Beinmei's series of milk powder has no added essence, light taste and good performance.

3. Comparison of basic nutrition

carbohydrate

↑

Summary:

① The carbohydrate content of Beinmei series 1 segment conforms to Chinese national standards, and the second segment and above conform to the reference range of the new national standard draft.

② Only the 4th section of Jing 'ai was added with maltodextrin, which had little nutritional value except providing heat, so it was deducted.

Glucose polymers (maltodextrin, glucose syrup solids, starch, sugar, etc. ) other series are not added, and the lactose content is high, which retains more nutritional value.

fat

↑

Summary:

① The fat content of Beinmei's whole series conforms to Chinese national standards.

2 Hongai used palm oil in the whole section, which may increase the probability of constipation of the baby, which is a deduction item;

Tongxiang, Classic Optimization, Ai Jing, paragraph 4 does not indicate the specific composition of vegetable oil, so I am not sure whether it contains palm oil, and silly dad will deduct points as appropriate.

protein

↑

Summary:

① The protein content of Beinmei series conforms to Chinese national standards. The advantages and disadvantages of specific proteins will be involved in the later analysis of characteristic enhancement formula.

Comparison of vitamins and minerals

↑

Summary:

① The contents of vitamins and minerals in Beinmei's full range meet Chinese national standards.

(2) Arnaudas, Qingai, Hongai, 2-3 sections lack manganese; Classic selection, childlike enjoyment, true, 2-3 paragraphs lack selenium.

Although it is in line with the current national standard, in the draft of the new national standard for comments, it is proposed that manganese and selenium should be adjusted as the essential components of the 2-3 stage milk powder. So everyone should pay attention.

Other series 1-3 are not short of vitamins or minerals.

② Three types of four-stage milk powder lack vitamins and minerals. However, because the four-stage milk powder is aimed at babies over 3 years old, their diet has been diversified, and there is no relevant standard for the four-stage milk powder at present, so here is just to remind everyone.

(3) Because the new national standard draft for comments greatly increased the minimum content of nicotinic acid in 1 milk powder and the minimum content of folic acid in 2-3 milk powder. Therefore, if the content of these substances in milk powder exceeds the "new" minimum, you will get extra points (marked as+). The specific situation is as shown above.

4. Strengthen the comparison of formulas

DHA/ARA

↑

Summary:

①0.3%≤DHA content ≤0.5% (accounting for the total fat content), or above 3.6mg/ 100kj, which is better for the baby's intellectual and visual development, and stupid dad will get extra points.

For Ai Jia 1-3 and Ainoda 1-2, the amount of DHA added is higher, and extra points are obtained (☆). The DHA content of other series is low, so it is hard to say how much effect can be achieved by eating milk powder alone.

② At the same time, the ratio of DHA and ARA in Ai Jia 1-3 and Ainoda 1-2 was 1:2, which was consistent with the ratio in breast milk and got more points (☆).

③ DHA/ARA was not added to the sections of Zhenyou and Tongxiang 1-3.

Conventional strengthening formula

↑

Summary:

① Conventional fortified formula, that is, although it is not an essential ingredient in the national standard, most milk powders will add nutrients, including choline, inositol, taurine, L-carnitine, nucleotides, dietary fiber and so on.

Adding conventional strengthening formula does not add points, only when it reaches a certain amount.

② The content of Beinmei series conventional fortified formula meets Chinese national standards.

③ All versions are rich in taurine, and 23 milk powder is rich in nucleotides, so extra points are given (marked as+). However, all versions have low choline content.

④ The whole segment of Bedolin lacks nucleotide; Children's enjoyment, classic optimization, and true Excellence lack choline in paragraphs 2-3; In the fourth stage, milk powder lacks choline, inositol, L-carnitine and nucleotides.

Feature reinforcement formula

↑

Summary:

① Characteristic fortified formula, that is, nutritional fortified substances only added to some milk powder, including lactoferrin, OPO, CPP, lutein, β-carotene, etc. Additional points can be obtained by adding special reinforcement formulas.

2 Lactoferrin: It helps to improve the baby's own immunity. Classic selection, children's enjoyment, Aijia, Hongai and Jingai are all added, but the amount of addition is not high, and Hongai is slightly higher.

③OPO: It can optimize the absorption of calcium and fatty acids. Classic selection, children's enjoyment, true, youth love is added in the whole paragraph, and the amount of addition is not much different.

④CPP (casein phosphopeptide): It can improve the intake, absorption and utilization of divalent minerals such as calcium, iron and zinc. Classic optimization, children's enjoyment, and Zhenyou 1-3 paragraphs have all been added.

⑤ Lutein: It helps to improve and protect eyesight. Green Love, Ai Jia, Red Love and Arnaudas are all added in the whole paragraph, and there is little difference between the paragraphs.

⑥ β-carotene: It can safely and effectively supplement vitamin A and promote vision development. Classic optimization and children's enjoyment are all added.

⑦ Although the classic optimization promotes the moderately hydrolyzed whey protein milk powder which is more easily absorbed, it is registered as ordinary formula milk powder, and there is not much hydrolyzed protein in the new ingredient list.

⑧ Bedolin does not add special strengthening formula to the whole section.

6. General comments

According to the above analysis, Stupid Dad made a detailed score (full score 100) for each version of Beinmei milk powder by comprehensive indicators such as milk source, milk-based raw materials, basic nutrition and fortified formula. The specific scores are as follows:

↑

According to the score, we can draw the following important conclusions:

1 and 1 milk powder

① Innoda ranked first, Green Love ranked second and Classic Optimization ranked third.

One of the gaps in the top three lies in raw materials. Anoda's milk source comes from New Zealand and is produced with fresh milk. Green love uses Irish milk powder, and the classic choice is Heilongjiang raw milk. The raw materials are not as good as Enoda.

Another difference is the fortified formula. Ainoda has a higher DHA content and a more reasonable ratio with ARA, while Green Love and Classic Optimization are at a disadvantage in this respect.

However, in the characteristic strengthening formula, Ainoda only added lutein 1, Green Love added lutein and OPO, and classic optimization added OPO, CPP and lactoferrin.

② The reasons for the low scores of other series are either because the quality of raw materials is not high, or because there is little addition of characteristic strengthening formula.

Suggestion: the paragraph 1 of Anoda is recommended. However, because the Anoda series has not passed the formula registration at present, it is not allowed to sell milk powder produced after 20 18 1. But as long as it is within the shelf life (its shelf life is 2 years), the quality of milk powder is still no problem.

If the treasure moms are not at ease, then it is not bad to choose the green love and classic optimization that have been registered through the formula. Green Love 1 is recommended for price insensitivity, and 1 is recommended for price sensitivity.

2, 2 stage milk powder

(1) Anoda ranked first, Green Love ranked second, and Ai Jia and Red Love tied for third.

The second stage of Ainoda and Lvai is basically the same as that of 1, the only difference is that manganese is not added from the second stage, so the mineral fraction is deducted.

In the second stage of classic optimization, points were deducted due to raw material mixed milk powder, low folic acid content and selenium deficiency, and the ranking also fell out of the top three.

Ai Jia No.2 ranked third with DHA advantages and two characteristic fortified formulas, but the milk source was relatively average; The second section of Hongai, which is also the third, has the advantages of milk source and two characteristic enhanced formulas, while other projects are not outstanding enough.

(2) A series of other problems mainly focus on the lack of raw materials, minerals and fortified formulas.

Recommendation: Recommend paragraph 2 of Enoda. If you care about formula registration, please recommend Green Love 2 for those who are not sensitive to price, and Aijia 2 for those who are sensitive to price.

Stage 3, 3 and 4 milk powder

(1) Love, green love tied for first place, and red love ranked third.

The score of Lvai 3 is the same as that of Lvai 2, but the reason for the decrease of the score of Ainoda is the decrease of DHA addition, so it is the same as that of Lvai.

The score of Hongai Section 3 is the same as that of Section 2, but Ai Jia Section 3 failed to keep the top three because the baby can eat more food after 1 year-old, so the score of DHA in the milk powder of Section 3 was lowered, and the score of Ai Jia Section 3 also declined.

(2) Paragraph 3 of other series is consistent with paragraph 2.

Recommendation: recommend paragraph 3 of Enoda. If you mind the formula registration, the price is not sensitive, recommend Green Love 3.

③ Because the vitamins and minerals of three four-stage milk powders are seriously lacking, it is not recommended.

price

In terms of price, Ben Dad selected the price data of official flagship stores in Beinmei (including Newfeier and Dr. Baby Care) and JD.COM in mid-February of 20 18 for your reference.

Combined with the score, the most expensive red love ranks in general, followed by green love, which is slightly better than red love, and the relatively cheap Anoda performs well.

↑

Well, this issue of Beinmei milk powder evaluation is over, and more domestic brand milk powder evaluations will continue to be launched, so stay tuned!

If you have any questions, please leave a message. Stupid dad will answer for you alone.

If you think the article is not bad, please forward more support!