Tianjin reporter investigation; & ampmdash
Foreigners have to pay more than 1000 yuan to learn driving in a driving school.
Are you registered in Tianjin or overseas? Recently, the reporter called Mr. Wang, the person in charge of Tianjin Volkswagen Driving School, as a driver and asked about related matters. The first question asked by the other party is this question. Subsequently, Mr. Wang introduced that the C 1 driver's license test costs 3,400 yuan for Tianjin residents and 4,300 yuan for foreign residents. The learning content is the same, and the latter takes longer than the former. Because of foreign household registration &; Press capital letters. , so the tuition is high. Mr. Wang said.
Teacher Wang explained that when the traffic control department of Tianjin Public Security Bureau determines the examination quota, there is a quota limit for foreign registered students, which is usually 6 1, that is, 6 local registered students are allocated 1 foreign registered students, so foreign registered students often cannot take the examination at the normal time like local registered students. The time for foreign registered students to study in driving school is generally 1.5 times that of local registered students, while local registered students generally study in driving school for 4 months, and foreign registered students need about 6 months.
The driving school in Tianjin is like this, which is determined by the policies of relevant departments, and there is nothing the driving school can do. Of course, we hope to recruit more students. President Mao of Tianjin Dongan Driving School told the reporter. He also revealed to reporters that after the National Day last year, the relevant departments further tightened the examination quota for foreign registered students, making it more difficult for foreign registered residents to apply for the exam.
The reporter also interviewed several other driving schools in Tianjin, and found that the fees charged by driving schools for foreign registered students are about 1000 yuan higher than those for local registered students, and the study time is several months longer. Take C 1 driver's license as an example. Students with local household registration generally charge between 3200 and 3400 yuan, and they can get a driver's license after studying for 4 to 5 months. However, the cost of foreign registered students is generally between 4 100 yuan and 4300 yuan, and the study time is generally more than half a year. The restrictive policies of the competent authorities have made it more difficult for foreigners to make an appointment for the exam. Driving schools have to extend the training time, resulting in increased operating costs. Finally, the relevant expenses will naturally be shared with the foreign registered students who take the driving test. The person in charge of a driving school in Tianjin said this when analyzing the reasons for the above situation.
The explanation and explanation of the traffic management department; & ampmdash
Due to the lack of examination ability, the number of places is limited.
The same driving school has different tuition fees just because of different household registration. Does this comply with the relevant provisions of relevant laws and regulations on price management? Bai Xiangdong, deputy director of the Comprehensive Adjustment Department of Tianjin Price Bureau, said that the driving and training market is completely liberalized at present, and the price bureau has not formulated a unified guidance price. Tuition fees are determined by the driving school in the market competition and are not managed by the price department.
How does the traffic control department explain the quota limit for foreign registered students to apply for driver's licenses reflected by the driving school? On March 4, the reporter went to the vehicle management office of the Traffic Management Bureau of Tianjin Public Security Bureau. The staff of the institute refused the reporter's interview on the grounds that they were not allowed to receive the media privately.
On March 5, the reporter called the Complaints and Reports Office of the Traffic Management Bureau of Tianjin Public Security Bureau as a consumer. A staff member of the office said that the driving and training fees are independently priced by the driving school and have nothing to do with the traffic control department. The city's restrictions on foreign household registration personnel to apply for driver's licenses are based on the current situation that the training ability of driving schools in this city and the ability of receiving examiners in vehicle management offices are insufficient. At present, the traffic control department of this city encourages foreigners to take the driver's license test at the place of registration. . Is there a legal basis for setting quota restrictions for foreign household registration applicants? The reporter asked. The staff member said. This is just an internal rule. .
Many consumers registered in other places find it difficult to agree with the idea of encouraging foreigners to return to their places of residence to get a driver's license. It takes at least two or three months to get a driver's license. Should I resign and go back to my hometown to get a driver's license? Ms. Dong told reporters this way.
Expert opinion &; mdash & ampmdash
There is no legal basis for driver's license discrimination.
According to the reporter's understanding, in the 1990s, the Ministry of Public Security issued a document asking applicants for driver's licenses to return to their domicile to take relevant examinations. 1,1The Measures for the Administration of Motor Vehicle Driving Licenses, which came into effect in September 1996, stipulates that a motor vehicle driving license shall be applied to the vehicle management office where the permanent residence is located. Those who have lived in their temporary residence for more than one year may apply to their temporary residence in dmv.
With the development of economy and the increase of social mobility, the Ministry of Public Security has adjusted relevant policies. On May 1 2004, the "Regulations on the Application and Use of Motor Vehicle Driving License" was implemented, allowing drivers to apply for driving licenses for small cars and small automatic cars in their temporary residence. This adjustment was cancelled and I lived for more than a year. These restrictions make it easier for people living in temporary places to apply for driver's licenses. The "New Regulations on the Application and Use of Motor Vehicle Driving License" promulgated by the Ministry of Public Security on June 5438+February 7, 2009 also stipulates that applicants for motor vehicle driving licenses living in temporary residence may apply to the vehicle management office of temporary residence.
Regarding the above practice in Tianjin, Associate Professor Tian Siyuan of Tsinghua University Law School said that the issuance of driver's licenses by administrative organs is an administrative licensing act. According to the administrative licensing law, administrative licensing behavior must be announced to the public. Without announcement, it shall not be used as the basis for the implementation of administrative license. Since there is no requirement for the "Regulations on the Application and Use of Motor Vehicle Driving License" and it has not been publicized to the public, it can only be judged from this point that Tianjin's practice does not comply with relevant laws and regulations.
In addition, at present, China's population flows frequently, and most cities, especially big cities, have many non-registered people working and living in these cities for many years, making great contributions to urban construction. At present, China's household registration system reform is under way, and the practice of restricting foreign household registration personnel to apply for driver's licenses does not conform to the direction of China's household registration system reform. Tian Siyuan said.
● Related links
There is no difference between driver's license and household registration in most cities.
The reporter investigated the driving test situation in some cities across the country and found that there is no difference between local residents and foreign residents applying for driving schools in most cities.
The staff of Beijing Bus Driving School told the reporter that foreign residents who sign up for driving school only need to provide the original temporary residence permit and do not charge tuition fees. There is no quota for foreign residents to take the driver's license test in this city.
The reporter also interviewed some driving schools in Shanghai, Shenzhen, Guangzhou, Wuhan, Jinan and other places by telephone, and learned that the driving schools in these cities have no policy restrictions on foreign residents learning to drive, and treat local residents equally.
However, the reporter found in the interview that driving schools in many provinces and cities, like driving schools in Tianjin, treat foreign and local registered students differently. Do you have a local account or external account? When the reporter called Xi 'an Judicial Driving School in Shaanxi, a staff member also asked this question first. To apply for a C 1 driver's license, the tuition fee for local registered students is 2,600 yuan, and that for foreign registered students is 3,200 yuan. The staff member explained that the reason for the difference is that the traffic control department of this city has restricted the number of examination places for students with foreign household registration. The staff of another driving school in the city also confirmed this statement to reporters.
Million car purchase subsidy