In the detailed rules for doctoral grading, the first author 1, the second author 0.5, the third author 0.33 and the fourth author 0.25.
The evaluation of doctoral materials consists of four aspects: learning experience, scientific research experience, award-winning situation and comprehensive level, with a full score of 100. Among them, learning experience accounts for 40%, scientific research experience accounts for 30%, award-winning situation accounts for 10%, and comprehensive level accounts for 20%.