1 should be granted neither.
2 For China Licheng Co., Ltd., the French announcement on February 4, 2007 was earlier than the filing date of February 5, 2007, and constituted the existing design.
For Henry Co., Ltd. in France, since the patent is territorial, according to the first-to-file principle, Henry Co., Ltd. has more than 6 months between its application in France and its application in China. It cannot enjoy priority, so China Licheng Co., Ltd.’s application in China is earlier than Henry Company’s application, which constitutes a conflicting application by Henry Company.