Entrusted by the family of * * *, Shanghai * * Law Firm appointed lawyer Wu Shengkai as the defense lawyer of * * * during the review and prosecution stage. The defense lawyer understands the case from the criminal suspect by reading the thesis of your hospital, and thinks that there are many doubts about the accusation of the criminal suspect in the prosecution opinion, so please verify it. The specific basis is as follows; (1) * * * arrived at Shanghai south railway station at noon on June 19, 2008, and had never been to Shanghai before.
* * * * and his girlfriend arrived at * * *' s sister's house in Kunming in May 2008, and stayed at her sister's house until June 17. Girlfriend * * * * * * *, sister * * * * * *, their families and neighbors can testify to the above facts. * * * * Mobile phone number: * * * * *, * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Please verify the above facts.
(2) The statements of * * * * and * * * about the time of the crime are inaccurate.
In the confession of * * * *, most of the confession time of * * * is "one day around June at noon/afternoon". In the confession of * * *, the confession time of * * * is mostly "noon/afternoon on a certain day in June". So, in which cases * * * was on the scene?
The above facts are still in doubt, please check them by the prosecutor.
(3) * * * said that after he came to Donghai Square, he often surfed the Internet in the "Forest Internet Cafe" and registered with his ID card before surfing the Internet. So was * * * surfing the Internet at the crime scene or in the "forest Internet cafe" at the time of the crime?
I urge the prosecutor to verify the above issues.
(4) * * * arrived at Donghai Square on June 9th 14: 00, when * * * * didn't know anyone else. So, how did he meet * * * in six days (* * * was arrested on June 25th)?
* * * * said in the confession on June 25th, 2008: "We just met in an Internet cafe a few days ago". So * * * Did you go to the Internet cafe when you arrived at Donghai Square at 2 pm on June 19? Which Internet cafe did you go to? Did you meet * * * Bo? Did you commit theft soon after you met him?
(5) The prosecution opinion found that * * * committed theft in the Yancang Construction Building in the afternoon of June 24th, 2008 with * *, * *, * * and others. After reviewing the case file, the defense lawyer raised the following questions:
1 and * * * said in their confessions on July 8, 2008: "We went to Jiading to steal on June 24 this year, because it was the day before we were arrested" (file page 17). In the case he confessed that day, he said: "Me and * * *, * *" "At 2 o'clock or more in the afternoon of June this year, the four of us stole RMB 1 100 in a public house in Jiading District by the same method, and the last four people shared it equally" (file No.65433).
Then, * * * will be in Jiading District at 2 or 3 o'clock on June 24th.
2.* * * said in the confession of June 2008 in 14: "On June 24th, 2008 (the day before we were arrested), at about 13, I, * * * * *, * * * went to one of the food markets in Yancang.
Then, * * * will be in Nanhui District around 1 on June 24th.
So how long did it take * * * to commit the theft? How did he travel back and forth between the two places in such a short time?
* * * claims that he has never committed theft. Then, according to the prosecution's opinion, * * * committed crimes twice in Yancang on the afternoon of June 24th. Only * * * in the file testified that * * * also participated in these two crimes. In the absence of other evidence, can it be concluded that * * * committed a criminal act on the afternoon of June 24th?
(6) * * * said that he had never been to Shanghai before June 19, 2008 and arrived in Shanghai on June 19. To sum up, there are many problems in this case at present. Please return to your hospital for supplementary investigation or make a decision not to prosecute.
I am here to convey
Shanghai Nanhui District People's Procuratorate