First, the cause of the incident
It is understood that Dalian Labor Park is open, so there are often some vendors sneaking in to sell balloons, sausages and toys. According to the management regulations of the park, unauthorized vendors are not allowed to operate illegally in the park. The hawker who sold balloons entered the park that day, and the staff repeatedly persuaded him to confiscate the hawker's balloons. After several unsuccessful requests, the peddler left the park. The staff released the balloon directly on the spot, which on the one hand made tourists feel pity, on the other hand, it also caused some environmental and safety hazards.
Second, why is the incident controversial?
Although many parks have internal management regulations for illegal operations, this phenomenon is not easy to manage. The staff in the park are not law enforcement officers. Some vendors know that the staff in the park have no law enforcement power, but they are unscrupulous and do not listen to dissuasion. The staff in the park will generally persuade the hawkers to leave and inform them of the relevant regulations in the park. Some vendors left and sold in the park the next day. Therefore, it is illegal for the park to confiscate hawker balloons, but after repeated persuasion, I think it is also a helpless move. However, it is obviously inappropriate to release balloons at the scene, and how to properly handle the items temporarily confiscated under extraordinary circumstances still needs to be considered.
Third, it is illegal to confiscate other people's property.
In addition, we should also pay attention to the confiscation and seizure of other people's goods by staff. According to the relevant provisions of the administrative regulations "Regulations on the Management of Security Services", security guards may not detain or confiscate other people's certificates and property; Anyone who commits this act shall be reprimanded by the public security organ according to the circumstances, his security guard certificate shall be revoked, and he shall be punished for public security management and investigated for criminal responsibility.
It is illegal for the staff in the video to confiscate and release balloons, and they should compensate the hawkers for their property losses. Staff should provide services in a civilized and legal manner, and do not belong to law enforcement personnel, and can take the form of persuasion for hawker misconduct within the management scope; If you are suspected of illegally occupying roads, you can report it to the urban management department; If you refuse to leave after repeated discouragement, you can report mediation to the public security department.
Therefore, on the one hand, the management of parks should take into account the actual situation and must be legal on a reasonable basis. Only in this way can disputes be properly and reasonably handled.