The doctor said the operation was a success.
Yesterday, 85-year-old Mao talked about his son Liu Dazhou's experience: Liu Dazhou was from Lihe Town, xinzheng city. He was diagnosed with gallstones by xinzheng city People's Hospital in June 5438+last year 10, and needed to have his gallbladder removed. The hospital arranged for Shen Yongsheng, director of general surgery, and Yang Guanghui, an anesthesiologist, to be in charge of the operation. Last year105 at 9: 00 am, 165438, Liu Dazhou was pushed into the operating room.
Liu Qifeng, the son of Liu Dazhou, said that at noon 12: 40 that day, the doctor Shen Yongsheng said to his family, "The operation was very successful." 13: 20, Liu Dazhou was still in a coma when he was pushed out of the operating room. Shen Yongsheng asked his family to call the patient's name to promote awakening. Liu Qifeng and his sister kept calling his father, but there was no response. At this time, because the medical staff were in a hurry to have lunch, they all said, "Nothing, just shout more." Liu Qifeng hopes to send his father to the intensive care unit for observation. Shen Yongsheng once again said, "Nothing." And let the medical staff send Liu Dazhou back to the fourth floor ward.
The patient stopped breathing for half an hour.
Liu Qifeng said that the nurses in the ward asked their families to hold the patient's chin and help him breathe. When Fan Fangfang, the nurse on duty that day, connected the monitor for the patient, she found that the patient's oxygen saturation was only half of the standard value. "At that time, she didn't inform the doctor. She took an oxygen mask, put it on my dad and left. There are no medical staff in the ward. I have been holding my father's chin to help him breathe since 13: 30. At 14, my father began to twitch all over, his lips turned purple, and he bit his tongue and couldn't breathe. "
Lu Qifeng hurried to call a doctor. In the corridor outside the ward, he saw Dr. Shen Yongsheng. 14: 20, Liu Qifeng pulled Shen Yongsheng into the ward, and the monitor showed that the patient's heartbeat dropped rapidly. After the anesthesiologist Yang Guanghui came to the ward, Shen Yongsheng asked Yang Guanghui to insert the airway quickly. Yang said that the insertion was not good, and he went out to find the airway after repeated requests from his family.
14: 30, the patient stopped breathing and heartbeat. Shen Yongsheng asked the nurse to go to the first floor to call the doctor in the intensive care unit. After more than 10 minutes of emergency rescue, Liu Dazhou still had a heartbeat, but he still didn't breathe. At this time, Yang Guanghui came to the ward with an airway. 15 My dad stopped breathing for half an hour when he was plugged into the airway. Liu Dazhou was diagnosed as "ischemic and hypoxic encephalopathy, persistent vegetative state" by the PLA Navy General Hospital in Beijing. Xinzheng city People's Hospital stopped supplying medical expenses in March this year, and was taken to court by the Liu family on April 23rd.
The trial hospital gave two different medical records.
Entrusted by the patient's family and law firm, in March this year, Henan Forensic Clinical Judicial Appraisal Institute made an appraisal through investigation: xinzheng city People's Hospital had serious fault and negligent behavior in the process of diagnosis and treatment of Liu Dazhou, which had a direct causal relationship with Liu's vegetative state, and the hospital should bear full responsibility.
In court, the defendant's hospital believed that its medical care met the standard, and the patient's postoperative cardiac arrest was caused by the patient's own heart disease. The plaintiff believes that before the operation, the hospital should confirm that Liu Dazhou has the surgical conditions, and the direct cause of the patient's vegetative state is extubation when the general anesthesia patient is not awake, which is seriously irresponsible for postoperative care.
In order to show that the hospital nursing meets the standard, the defendant's agent submitted the relevant medical records, and the plaintiff's agent also presented the medical records in court. There are two nursing records and long-term doctor's orders, both of which are stamped with the official seal of the hospital, but one of them is the same as that provided by the defendant, and the other is obviously different from the original one mentioned by the defendant.
The plaintiff's lawyer questioned the nature of xinzheng city People's Hospital, but Liu Hongwei, the vice president of the hospital as the defendant's agent, could not answer who was the president of the hospital. It turned out that the defendant claimed that the hospital was a non-profit organization, but the legal representative was the chairman. The plaintiff believes that it is the enterprise nature of the hospital that causes the serious dereliction of duty of medical staff.
Yesterday 16: 30, the presiding judge announced that it is necessary to carefully study whether the case needs to be re-appraised through discussion by the collegial panel, and when the court will be held will be notified separately.
What is the basis for claiming sky-high prices?
The plaintiff filed a one-time claim of 2.99 million yuan, which was introduced by the staff of gongyi city People's Court. This is the first time they have encountered such a high civil claim. Then, what is the basis for the Liu family's accumulated claim of more than 654.38+million yuan?
According to Mao, on June 25th last year, 165438+ In view of Liu Dazhou's serious illness, at the request of his family, the hospital transferred the patient to Beijing Navy General Hospital, and the monthly life-sustaining treatment cost was as high as 60,000 to 70,000 yuan. During the treatment period, xinzheng city People's Hospital provided 3 1 1,000 yuan for treatment, and the renewal fee was stopped on April 20th this year.
The old lady said that her son was the pillar of the family before the operation, with an investment of more than 654.38+100,000 yuan, and opened a number of enterprises and a nursery, with considerable income. After his son was treated as a vegetable, the enterprise was left unattended. The Liu family spent all their savings to treat their son, and now they borrow money everywhere.
It is understood that Liu's claim for compensation is carried out in stages, of which the first claim is 2.99 million yuan, and the deadline is 65438+February 3 1 this year, including treatment fee, nursing fee, lost time, disability allowance, disability appraisal fee, transportation fee, disability equipment fee, enterprise economic loss compensation and mental damage compensation of 300,000 yuan. From now on, according to the calculation of 70,000 yuan necessary to maintain Liu Dazhou's life every month, the Liu family will claim about 800,000 yuan from the hospital every year. The claim period is based on the average life expectancy of 72 years in Henan Province, and claims are made according to the plan of 10 year, plus the accumulated first claim of 10 million yuan.