On July 7, 2020, the People's Court of Qingshanhu District, Nanchang City, Jiangxi Province publicly pronounced the criminal incidental civil lawsuit of Bao, Ren Moqiang, Zhang and Qu Mokuan, and illegally detained the Academy in the first instance.
Bao was sentenced to two years and ten months' imprisonment, Ren Mouqiang was sentenced to two years and seven months' imprisonment, Zhang was sentenced to one year and ten months' imprisonment, Qu Moukuan was sentenced to 11 months' imprisonment, exempted from criminal punishment, and dismissed the claims of plaintiffs Luo Mou, Chen Moumou and Zhou Moumou in incidental civil litigation.
Defendants, Bao, Ren Moqiang, Zhang and Qu Mokuan illegally deprived others of their personal freedom, all of which constituted the crime of illegal detention. Among them, Bao, Ren Mouqiang and Zhang played a major role in the criminal process of * * *, and they were all principal offenders;
Qu Mokuan and Chen Mou played a secondary role in the same criminal process, and they were both accomplices. Defendant, Bao, Ren Mouqiang, have surrendered plot, Zhang has no surrendered plot but has confessed plot, and Qu Moukuan has confessed plot.
Defendant Chen Mou, as a teacher of Zhang Yu College, was mainly responsible for teaching. He only took part in guarding the three students in this case in shifts according to the arrangement of the school under the condition of insufficient instructors. He is an accessory to this case because he has surrendered himself. If the circumstances of the crime are minor and there is no need to be sentenced to punishment, criminal punishment may be exempted.
This case is accompanied by the plaintiff's claim for compensation for medical expenses and transportation expenses. Because the evidence provided is not enough to prove its claim, it should bear adverse consequences, and the court does not support its claim. His claim for a public apology, tuition refund and compensation for mental damage is not within the scope of incidental civil action stipulated by law, so it is not supported. Accordingly, the court made the above judgment.
Extended data victims prepare for appeal:
After the verdict was pronounced in the first instance, the defendant Chen Mou accepted the verdict; Bao Mou, Ren Moqiang, Zhang Mou and Qu Mokuan all expressed the need to consider whether to appeal; Plaintiffs Luo Mou and Zhou Moumou in incidental civil action appealed in court; The plaintiff in the incidental civil action, Chen Moumou, said that Chen's opinion needs to be sought before deciding whether to appeal; The judgment has not yet taken legal effect.
The victim students at the trial site said that the criminal part of the sentence was too light, and they were prepared to apply to the procuratorate for a protest, and the civil part would also appeal. Others worry that the civil judgment is inconclusive, no more victims will come out to defend their rights, and the case will be slowly forgotten.
China Com- "Zhang Yu College" case verdict! The victim students think that the sentence in Zhang Yu College case is too light.