"My appeal is that I hope Xiaoyu can repay the loan money. The compensation should be compensated. " "I must fulfill her last wish." Xiao Xiao Hu (a pseudonym) said. On February 9, Xiaohu told Tianmu news reporter that after more than 40 days of hardships, the family decided to expose this matter, because under the threat of Xiaoyu, her sister mortgaged the property to buy her a luxury car, which drove her to a dead end. Xiaoyu denied everything, refused to take responsibility and apologized, hoping that more girls would take warning and protect themselves.
A small suicide note provided by the interviewee
The girl committed suicide after mortgaging the real estate and buying a luxury car for her boyfriend.
"What about 7 18?" Xiaoyu asked. "I know!" Short stories. "Go and fix it." "To 7 18." "The sooner the better." "7 18, the medicine will get rid of the disease." ...... In April 2020, in Xiao Yu's small chat record, Xiao Yu kept saying that 7 18 was a Porsche sports car, which gave people a sense of oppression.
At that time, Xiao Xiao was still a senior in Hubei Academy of Fine Arts. How could he possibly have the ability to buy Xiaoyu a sports car of around 800,000? It turned out that her little parents had prepared a house for her.
Photos of Xiao Xiao and Xiao Lang's chat records were provided by the respondents.
A screenshot of a chat with Xiaoxiao provided by Xiao Lang, the principal of the primary school, shows that Xiaoxiao told the seniors the secrets hidden in her heart from June 5438 to October 2020. "In June 2020, I was in a period of depression, and Xiaoyu had the idea of buying a car. In July, Xiaoyu bought a BMW 5 Series in full. How did the money come from? Because under his threat, especially mentally, I mortgaged my house to the bank for 80 10 years, and both of them had to pay back 5500 yuan every month. Because my account has a lot of water in a short period of time, in addition to the agency fee, I authorized to pay 760,000 to his card. "
Unable to afford a Porsche, Xiaoyu bought a BMW with a mortgage of 565,438+100000, and registered it in his own name. Xiaoyu only got back 265,438+100000. "In the chat record, Xiaoyu admitted that the fare was a small loan. For the loan that needs to be shared by two people, the attorney said that from August last year to 65438+February, Xiaoyu only transferred 4,000, 3,000 and 2,000 loan fees to Xiaoxiao, and the rest was borne by her sister alone. " Xiaohu said that only five months later, in mid-February of 12, Xiaoyu sold BMW at a discount and borrowed money to drive a Mercedes-Benz. "My sister has completely collapsed. Xiaoyu has no income and has to repay the loan. How can she pay her mortgage? "
65438+February 9 1 1, Xiao Xiao wrote a paragraph in the memo: "Yesterday, Xiao Yu said that he would give the air to me. He said he would sell the car and help me pay back the loan. Then he took a lot of medicine and took a knife. He told me to go out. He came out of the room with a scar on his arm and a lot of blood. Xiaohu said there was a recording to prove it.
On February 30th, 65438, Xiaoxiao suffered from extreme stomach discomfort due to taking antidepressants. She hopes Xiaoyu will take her to the hospital. Xiaoyu claimed that she wanted to sleep, so she had to ask her senior Xiao Lang for help. "In the afternoon, she told me that she vomited badly, but before I got there, she just ..." Xiao Lang said.
A small memo provided by the interviewee.
Lawyers said that "the death of PUA" is difficult to evaluate in criminal law.
Xiaoxiao 20 19 1 1 met her boyfriend in a dating APP. Xiaohu said that during the epidemic, when my sister was in her hometown in Jingzhou, she locked herself in her room and chatted with her mobile phone every day.
"Listen to her description, her boyfriend is very handsome, very gentle, very doting on her, with a high degree, or a university teacher, with good family conditions. Presumably, few girls can refuse such boys. " "But in fact, that boy is unemployed. He used to design it for himself, and he has always won a little sympathy because of his depression, "said a small college student, Cui Cui."
"She asked me in September that there was a civil dispute case of 700,000 to 800,000, and she wanted me to ask a lawyer for help." Xiao Lang said, "But I didn't know that she had encountered such a problem herself."
Xiaohu said that after the autopsy, the police said that her sister committed suicide due to depression and ruled out homicide. "On the day of my sister's accident, the police didn't knock on the rental door of my sister and Xiaoyu, but kicked it open. Her boyfriend was sleeping at that time. " Xiaohu said that her family didn't know that she had a boyfriend, that she had depression, and that she had privately mortgaged a real estate loan.
The reporter tried to contact her little boyfriend Xiaoyu to understand the situation, but the phone was always turned off. Xiaohu said that Xiaoyu never saw his small home again after the incident, and later the phone was turned off. The chat record between Zhang Xiaohu and Xiaoyu shows that Xiaoyu refused to provide the tiger with his location.
The chat records of Xiao Hu and Xiao Yu provided by the interviewee.
"PUA is a legal issue and there is no way to form a conviction." Tiger said: "My sister chose this road because she felt that such a big loophole made her breathless. She can't make up for it herself, can't make it back, and can't explain it to her family. "
Mix was killed by PUA. What kind of legal responsibility should a boyfriend bear? Lawyer Huang Honglian of Zhejiang Lin Jing Law Firm said that from the perspective of criminal law, suicide is a punishment for one's right to life, and no third person can intervene, so the act of suicide cannot be related to external factors, and there is no causal relationship in criminal law. Whether it is emotional disputes or property disputes, it is not enough for a person to end his life, so it is difficult to evaluate in criminal law.
"This kind of behavior constitutes a civil tort at most. This person abused her in behavior, and PUA did harm to her spirit, which eventually led to her suicide. It may be an infringement in civil, but it does not constitute a crime in criminal law. " Huang Honglian said.
In addition, the lawyer hired by Xiaohu said that the property dispute involved in the case will definitely win, and under normal circumstances, 540,000 yuan can be recovered, but whether there is money is still a problem.