In a shopping mall in Yongzhou City, Hunan Province, 17-year-old girl Li was attacked by 52-year-old boy Lei. 18-year-old colleague Hu had an argument with Lei at the scene and sent Lei to the monitoring room for monitoring. Ray took the opportunity to escape, followed by Hu. In the process, Hu kicked Hu down and injured him.
The case is simple, the process is clear, and there is monitoring as evidence. Who is kind and just? Who is dirty and who is guilty? I believe this is also clear at a glance.
However, the police's preliminary handling result was somewhat unexpected: the molester only compensated the girl 300 yuan, while the boy who prevented the molester from escaping was asked to pay 200,000 yuan, and was criminally detained for "intentional injury"! The boy's father burst into tears: it's all my fault. If I had known this, I would have given the wretched man 200 thousand!
Writing here, I can't help but feel puzzled and helpless. Law is a tool to punish evil and promote good, and it is the last line of defense for social fairness and justice. However, the legal application and legal effect of this case run counter to it! Ray was the first one who molested, broke the law and ran away. He is the original murderer and the chief culprit of this case. Young Hu is the one who fought against it. He is a just and brave man. Although his negligence is improper, it is essentially different from "intentional injury" How can you be "criminally detained"? How will this affect the hearts of the public? How much is it worth to be brave?
The society needs temperature, the people need warmth, and the socialist legal system needs the awe-inspiring righteousness and responsibility of law enforcers!
The boy was detained because the indecent man was kicked out of the hospital and claimed 200,000 yuan. The boy's family refused to pay compensation. As a result, the police at the police station failed to mediate, and a criminal detention notice was issued to Lin Hu (a pseudonym), a boy of 18 years old.
Lin Hu's father said in an interview that he regretted not selling the iron to the rogue molester for 200,000 yuan. Because Lin Hu is only 18 years old, this criminal detention is likely to leave a criminal record, which will affect the children's future.
Looking back on the whole case, Lin Hu's motivation should be "being brave". This happened in the afternoon of June 1 2020 in a shopping mall in Yongzhou, Hunan. At that time, Lin Hu and female classmate Li Ai were shopping. As a result, 52-year-old Lei Moumou deliberately stepped forward and touched Li Ai's chest with his elbow. Then, I went to argue with the obscene male Lei Moumou, and the two held their own words and went to the security room.
After monitoring in the security room, it was found that Lei Moumou was indeed deliberately indecent, and he had also molested another girl before. When his eyes were bad, he was about to run away, but Lin Hu hurt his hand, so he had to kick him to stop running away.
On the same day, the police intervened in the investigation, and Lei Moumou admitted the indecent act and compensated the girl 300 yuan.
A few days later, Lei was hospitalized. The police called the boy's family and asked them to mediate. At first, his family paid 1000 yuan for the operation. Later, Lei demanded compensation of 200,000 yuan, but his family refused.
A month later, on August 2 1 day, the local police issued a notice of criminal detention to Lin Hu, a teenager aged 18, and detained him in the detention center.
Judging from the elements of the whole case, there is no doubt that the obscene nature of Lei Moumou has been characterized. Lin Hu's motive for kicking him to stop him from escaping should be to stop the "criminal" from escaping, which is a courageous act, not the "intentional injury" in the police report. Intentional injury is a personal grudge; It is a great righteousness to be brave.
The verdict of this case will once again affect the social atmosphere. Looking back now, the Peng Yu case in 2006, though not serious in nature, had a far-reaching impact. Many young people's three views have been seriously impacted. The moral behavior of helping the elderly with kindness was demonized for a time, and most people said they dared not implement it.
The ethical and moral environment of society has been greatly influenced. Until now, when it comes to helping the "elderly", most people's first reaction is to be afraid of being misunderstood.
The same is true of Lin Hu, a boy of 18 years old. If the public security organs make any mistakes in the process of handling, it will cause bad public opinion and guidance. Our social and moral environment may be destroyed again.
In addition, according to the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Law, any citizen has the right to arrest and hand over criminals at the crime scene.
If Lin Hu is finally sentenced, whether there are legal problems or not, it will be another blow to the moral construction of the country.
If this kind of thing happens again in the future, considering the consequences of the Lin Hu case in Hunan, who will stand up to help others and stop the crime? The traditional virtue of our nation "bravery" must be redefined.
I hope that Hunan Public Prosecution Law can pay attention to ways and methods on the basis of fair law enforcement and give a satisfactory answer to the people of the whole country.
Besides, no matter what the final result is, I want to say, "Lin Hu, you are very good. Your experience should not be your stain, but your medal. "
Lao Sun believes that this question is worth pondering: In real life, why do good deeds make people so confused? This kind of blocking behavior, even if it is "excessive", is absolutely correct in morality and should be praised. However, how did it become "intentional injury?" The molester repeatedly pushed the girl's chest on purpose? This makes the moral standard in my heart vague, the standard of justice in heaven is unbalanced, and even subverts my cognition of "punishing evil and promoting good"
In this case, the boy had to pay 200,000 yuan for hurting and molesting a man, and was also detained. It seems that this wretched man is a hooligan with no moral bottom line. He should be investigated for legal responsibility, otherwise, it will be difficult to be a gentleman and unpopular!
I think: this case should be re-investigated, the criminal detention of boys should be lifted as soon as possible, and the molestation of men should be brought to justice! Why did it take more than two months to criminally detain Hu?
The cause of the incident occurred on June, 2020 1 day. At that time, Hu Mou, age 18, and Li Mou (female), age 17, were shopping. The 52-year-old suddenly attacked Li when he was not looking. Hu, age 18, is going to stop the salty pig hand and chase it all the way. Lei Mou, 52, can't run past 60. In order to prevent escape, Hu stepped forward and kicked him, but his first two feet missed. He was kicked by the third foot and then taken to the police station. Lei compensated 300 yuan, who was molested, to pay for the taxi and medical examination, and signed an agreement. After that, he didn't blame each other. It should be here by rights. What happened afterwards?
On June 6, the local police station called Hu and said that Lei was hospitalized (according to the crime of indecency, he should have been placed in administrative detention). Four days later, Hu's father paid Lei an operation fee of 1 ten thousand yuan. /kloc-more than 0/month later, that is, on July 4, the local police station asked Hu and Lei to come to the hospital for investigation. Please remember that this is.
On August 2 1 day, the local police issued a criminal detention notice to Hu. At present, Hu is already at the police station. Yesterday, Hu's father publicly reported on the Internet, and the media also intervened. At one time, there were different opinions.
Mainly at the beginning, according to Hu's father, Lei's injury report was a minor injury. The final judicial appraisal is: comminuted fracture of right humeral bone and comminuted fracture of right humeral intertrochanteric. Two injuries constitute minor injuries. I have seen the power of Foshan's shadowless feet in movies, but is it so powerful for a boy of 18 years old to kick? What happened from June/KLOC-0 to August 24th, I believe we will find out.
I read the case report, which did not reflect the punishment for the indecent man, nor did it reflect that Hu kicked Ray in the process of stopping him from escaping. These two points are very important from the legal point of view. Relevant lawyers also said that Hu's behavior is a twisting behavior according to law. Even if Hu and Li are boyfriend and girlfriend, it doesn't affect Hu's conclusion of being brave.
I believe that Yongzhou procuratorate will make a fair and just result. Nowadays, obscenity and candid photos can often be seen on buses and subways. Society needs someone to stand up and stop them. It needs everyone to uphold justice. Only in this way can our travel be safer, and at the same time, we must severely crack down on those bad behaviors of being fake, touching porcelain, peeping and greedy.
In ancient times, there was a feat of signing letters to plead guilty. Today, I need everyone to give me a push and call for more people to do justice.
This matter makes people feel anxious. The brave guy was detained, but the wretched man was at large, trying to extort 200,000 damages. "Good people are unlucky and bad people are reasonable", which is totally inconsistent with the education and concepts we received since childhood.
Recently, in a shopping mall in Yongzhou, Hunan Province, a 52-year-old man attacked a girl 17 years old and her fellow villager Hu (18 years old). In order to prevent the obscene man from escaping, Lei Mou fell down. When the public security organ intervened, the two sides agreed to compensate the girl 300 yuan for the inspection fee and transportation fee, and they would not blame each other in the future. Ray didn't get any punishment for his behavior. Unexpectedly, five days later, things changed dramatically. Leimou, a wretched man, said that he was fractured after being kicked that day and needed surgery. Hu's parents paid 65,438 yuan for Lei's operation. Lei refused to accept it and claimed 200,000 yuan. Hu's family couldn't get it and didn't agree. The police detained Hu in the detention center for "intentional injury".
Young ray's brave behavior brought a curse on himself. It should be the duty and responsibility of every citizen to stop criminal acts and hand over criminal suspects to public security organs! ! Ray's injury was an accident. He only kicked. How can we determine that he intentionally hurt? Ray also spoke, demanding compensation of 200,000. The crime of indecency that he was later identified by the public security organs has not been dealt with.
The experience of young Hu Man is chilling. There are also "the girl who helped the aunt fall was blackmailed", "the rescued person drowned to save others, but the rescued person ignored it" and so on. As well as the Hu incident, people can't help feeling that people who do good deeds will not come to a good end, but also warn themselves and their families to "do not do good deeds, just sweep the snow in front of the door", and the whole social atmosphere has been seriously affected.
The state has always advocated "promoting righteousness and spreading positive energy". What is the purpose of setting up the "Courageous Fund"? Is to let everyone help each other, care for each other and build a harmonious and friendly society.
May justice be done and criminals be brought to justice. Don't let good people get hurt. I believe that the law must be just and will give a perfect answer to this matter.
The right path in the world is vicissitudes! ! !
Personally, this is caused by the differences, contradictions and conflicts between law and reason.
From a legal point of view, obscene men attack their chests when they see color, and both men and women call the police to deal with it. Infringement terminated. The three men came to the monitoring room to watch the video. During the period, the man wanted to escape, and the boy slammed his feet to prevent the other party from being slightly injured. At this time, the public security organs believe that the boy's behavior is aimed at the escape of obscene men, which has nothing to do with illegal infringement. It should be a story injury, so he should be detained and compensated 200,000 yuan.
Simply put, when a boy molests a man and attacks his girlfriend's chest, he can kick him. Once it stops. I can't kick any more, and I can't kick anywhere else. That is not allowed by law. From a rational point of view, it is generally believed that this is a coherent process, whether at the scene of the incident or in the monitoring room. Boys will be angry when they see obscene men attacking their chests, but they will hold back their feet and call the police first, and then investigate and monitor them. The wretched man ran away for fear of losing face. Boys think each other is squeezing themselves. If people run away, things will go away. So anger started from my heart and kicked at the wretched man.
It is generally believed that this is a continuous process from beginning to end and should not be treated separately. Just like a robber robbing a bank and grabbing money, the crime is over. After calling the police, the robber slipped out with the money. Can't we just chase him out and stop him? Therefore, in this world, some things are legal and unreasonable, and some things are reasonable and illegal. In the end, it is mostly through the pressure of discussion, and the people's hearts have always been resolved as appropriate. what do you think?
(Original, the picture is from the Internet, and the infringement is jointly deleted) 17-year-old female classmate was attacked by a 52-year-old man, and the male classmate was arrested to prevent her from being injured. The news triggered the attention and heated discussion of netizens. The mother of a female classmate gave feedback on the Internet. After the daughter was attacked, her chest pain was unbearable, so she took out her mobile phone and dialed 1 10. The man found the alarm and started running. When the male students saw it, they rushed to catch up and tried to stop the man from escaping. Because the male classmate injured his arm in May, his arm was bandaged and he couldn't hold the man. In desperation, he kicked the man. Unexpectedly, the man who attacked the chest fell and was injured on the first floor of the shopping mall, which was a minor injury.
Later, accompanied by his family, the male classmate mediated with the male chest attacker at the police station. Who knows that in the mediation process, the male chest attacker asked for 200,000 yuan. The family said that the police station said that if you can settle this matter with money, we will not file a case. Perhaps because the mediation between the two sides failed, the male student was criminally detained by the police on August 2 1 day on suspicion of intentional injury.
Seeing that the male classmate was detained by the police station, the female classmate called the police handling the case. The police said: "The fact that the male attacked the chest has been established, but the two minor injuries of the male attacked the chest were caused by male students. Whatever the reason, the injury was really caused by that male classmate. That male classmate didn't mean it. Is it unintentional? " The female classmate cried and felt very sorry for him. He was going to be detained while helping me.
In fact, a similar case happened some time ago. It happened in Nantong, Jiangsu. On May 26th, Mr. Sun drove to the river to wash earthworms. When he came back, he found that his wallet had been stolen. Looking around, I found a man riding a motorcycle turned the throttle and ran away when he saw him. Mr. Sun immediately drove after him, causing the thief to be knocked down and broken during the forced stop. Mr. Sun was finally released on bail pending trial by the police on suspicion of intentional injury.
In response to the case of the man who attacked the chest, I saw a lawyer say: First, the male students did not intentionally hurt the man who attacked the chest.
Second, even if the male students are at fault, it is also a fault of negligence or overconfidence, but the male who attacked the chest did not meet the standard of serious injury, so the male students should not be investigated for criminal responsibility.
I agree with this lawyer. Male students are not only innocent, but also should be praised. If the police determine that this is intentional injury, it will limit citizens' right to defense to a certain extent. Seriously, it will make good people feel cold and make bad people more arrogant!
What happened:
On June 1 day, Li Ai (a pseudonym), a 7-year-old girl from Yongzhou/Kloc, Hunan Province, was attacked in the chest by a 52-year-old man with his elbow. Lin Hu (pseudonym), a male classmate, was injured while controlling the man who attacked the chest. On August 2 1, he was criminally detained by the Public Security Bureau of Lengshuitan District, Yongzhou City, and is now detained in the detention center. However, the parties learned that the man who attacked the chest may be issued a notice of administrative detention.
Added content (timeline):
On June 1 day, Lei intentionally touched his chest with his elbow. Through monitoring, Lei admitted the indecent behavior.
On June 1 day, after the girl called the police, Hu and his classmates stared at Lei in the monitoring room, waiting for the police to arrive.
On June 1 day, Lei broke away while waiting, and Hu immediately chased him. However, due to hand injury (fixed with plaster at that time), he had to kick the block with his foot, and the first two feet failed to kick, and the last foot caused Lei to fall.
On June 1 day, the police arrived at the scene to mediate between the two parties, reached a mediation agreement, and compensated the girl 300 yuan (as an inspection fee and travel expenses) by pressing her handprint.
Pay attention to a detail: on June 1 day, Lei fell, and nothing seemed to happen after the fall. After the police arrived, he completed the mediation process, admitted the facts and signed a letter of commitment. And at that time, there was no mention of arm and leg pain caused by falling. But magic came. ......
On June 6, the police informed Hu that Lei was hospitalized after falling from the building and was being treated in Yongzhou Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital.
A few days later, Lei Mou, who was not seriously injured after a fall, actually suffered a comminuted fracture of his arm and leg a few days after the injury. !
Don't pull other, answer me first:
On June 1 day, it is a fact that Lei was molested and fell, and it is also a fact. It is also true that Ray accepted indecency and compensated 300 yuan that day. It is also true that ray paid for going home.
On June 5, the problem was: four days later, Lei was hospitalized, saying it was a comminuted fracture, and the police detained the courageous male classmate. Lei Mou, did you climb home on June 1?
Don't say it doesn't make sense. It doesn't make sense in jurisprudence and pathology.
Think about the Peng Y case. How many people are involved? Who dares to help the old lady? Later, the old lady fell down again, which was helped by the pupils. It was the pupils who stumbled when they were blackmailed. Fortunately, some passing college students were more sensible and took surveillance videos. Obviously, the old lady fell by herself.
The year before last, the flower-armed man cut the cyclist with a knife, but he was killed by the cyclist. Finally, the cyclist was sentenced to self-defense.
Last year, another girl killed the man who broke into her house with a kitchen knife.
Great joy! This incident threw cold water on us again today?
If the facts are not clarified, the boys will still be detained.
Who will dare to help if someone gets hurt in the future?
Encourage courage every day, not simply deal with it. Listen to the voices of the masses.
What do you want me to think? Being brave, he was criminally detained by the police, and he had to pay 200,000 yuan to the indecent man, but the indecent man was acquitted. This result is really unacceptable. If this happens in the future, who will dare to be brave? Isn't this just shielding criminals? If you molest a woman and get beaten, and you can still get 200 thousand compensation, wouldn't society be in chaos?
It happened in a shopping mall in June 1. The obscene man deliberately touched Ai's chest with his arm, and a colleague friend of Ai had an argument with him. Peer friends punched the indecent man, resulting in two comminuted fractures of the indecent man. After the court ruled, it caused minor injuries.
The indecent male parents sued their friends and demanded 200,000 yuan in compensation. The accompanying friends disagreed, and the police station criminally detained the friends.
If the victim's parents know about it, even if they sell iron, they will have to pay compensation. We can't let this friend leave a criminal record at the police station.
It is suggested that this event can be reasonably judged. I don't think we should be detained for obscenity. Compensation is also flirting with men and flirting with her. No mental damage?
First of all, I declare my opinion: the law will not spare a bad person, nor will it wronged a good person. In this Yongzhou incident, my personal opinion is that Hu, who kicked a man who molested a girl, is a good man. His behavior can be regarded as self-defense and courageous. I hope that the relevant departments can enforce the law impartially after careful examination, release Hu Moumou who was detained as soon as possible, and bring Lei Moumou who molested the girl to justice.
Surveillance video of Lei's indecent girl
The public security organ has identified the obscene behavior of Lei Moumou. On June 1 day of this year, a girl of 17 years old in Yongzhou, Hunan Province was attacked by a 52-year-old man, Lei Moumou, with an elbow in her chest, and Hu Moumou, who was also a male classmate, trampled her while preventing her from escaping. Afterwards, Lei Moumou was given administrative punishment, and Hu Moumou was criminally detained on August 2 1 day 19 on suspicion of intentional injury (minor injury).
And I checked the surveillance of the mall and found that Ray had molested more than one girl. Before that, he molested another girl by attacking his chest.
So shortly after the alarm, the molested girl received a phone call from the police station, saying that Lei Moumou had admitted that he had hit the girl in the chest and was willing to make a reconciliation and apologize. So the girl came to the police station, and Lei Moumou signed a reconciliation book under the mediation of the police, and also compensated the girl for 300 yuan's inspection fee and fare.
Case notification issued by lengshuitan Public Security Bureau
After the collision, the girl Ai Moumou was angry and painful. With the help of the security guard in the mall, she checked the monitoring and confirmed that Lei did have indecent intentions. But just when everyone was watching the video playback, Lei Moumou took the opportunity to run out of the monitoring room. Ai moumou couldn't chase it because of chest pain, so Hu moumou chased it to the parking lot outside the mall.
Because Hu's arm was injured, there was no way to stop Lei from escaping by hand. In case of necessity, he can only use his legs to stop the other party from escaping. Hu Moumou kicked three feet at Lei Moumou, of which the first two feet did not kick the latter, and the last kick kicked Lei Moumou, causing him to fall to the ground. After judicial appraisal, the comminuted fracture of Lei's right humeral head and the comminuted fracture of the right intertrochanteric femur are all fresh fractures, and the two injuries constitute the first grade of calf injury respectively.
The detention notice issued by the public security organ to Hu Moumou
Later, Lion, a middleman found by Lei Moumou, claimed 200,000 damages from Hu Moumou. Hu Moumou's parents paid10,000 yuan for Lei Moumou in June, and the two families met at the police station in July 14. The middleman that Lei Moumou looked for seemed to be a "social person", so he took care of Hu Moumou's father and asked for 200,000. Hu moumou's father considered his family's family.
After the request was rejected, on August 2 1 day, his son Hu was detained in criminal detention.
Shunfeng conclusion: At present, the police do not agree with Hu Moumou's determination of being brave. Courageous generally refers to the act of standing up, protecting national interests, public interests and the personal and property safety of others, and stopping illegal acts, generally aiming at the ongoing illegal acts. In this case, Lei Moumou's illegal behavior has been terminated, so Hu Moumou's behavior is not to prevent indecency, but to prevent Lei Moumou from escaping from Hu Moumou, which is more similar to legal self-help behavior.
Feng is not a legal professional, but what I want to ask is whether the whole process of criminal escape is illegal. Is it illegal for a wanted criminal suspect to escape? If all these are illegal, then does the police think that it is illegal for Lei to escape? Do citizens have the obligation to assist the police in arresting people? To be clear, this case is actually very clear.