In his view, it is "nonsense" to rashly convict a doctor without the re-appraisal conclusion of the Chinese Medical Association. "In the past, having children was the' gate of death', and everyone's physical quality was different. Who wants to be an obstetrician if all puerperal women have to put doctors in prison? "
According to an in-depth investigation by the Beijing Youth Daily reporter, it seems that the "conviction" of the Li case today is accidental. In fact, there are many inevitable factors: shortage of medical resources, overload of work intensity, long-term distrust of doctor-patient relationship, and external intervention ... interlocking, she has been pushed to the "dock".
On March 26th this year, the original trial was postponed for the fourth time by Changle City Court, "because the jurors were absent". Previously, the defense's application for re-appraisal of the Chinese Medical Association and the request for expert assistants to appear in court were not adopted by the court.
Yesterday, the application for inviting expert assistants to appear in court was submitted to the court again.
"Who can give me a visible justice?" Li asked this question.
Preserve the body
In Beishan, Hangcheng Street, Changle City, Fujian Province, a corpse was kept in a freezer numbered D5 for 1 193 days. Its owner, Chen Yanfang, died at the age of 28, and the cause of death was "postpartum death in hospital".
As a corpse "preserved" here, Chen Yanfang is not the oldest one; But the staff of the funeral home said, "There are longer than her, but they are all nameless bodies. Due to unknown identity, civil affairs requires retention. "
According to the daily average freezing storage fee of Changle funeral home 100 yuan, Beijing Youth Daily reporter found that the storage fee of this body has been about 6.5438+0.2 million yuan.
There is an old saying in China, "Be buried with peace" and "The deceased is like a husband". What makes a deceased person still have no real rest 40 months after his death?
A "civil reconciliation agreement" signed on February 4 this year gave the answer. Party A's Changle Hospital and the father of the deceased who died in a medical accident agreed: "Party A will compensate Party B for medical expenses, nursing expenses, in-hospital food subsidies, death compensation (including the living expenses of the dependents), funeral expenses, transportation expenses, appraisal fees, and mental damages in a lump sum of 6,543.8 yuan +0.5 million yuan (note: the hospital will bear the expenses for the preservation of the patient's remains during the medical appraisal proceedings)".
It turned out that this body involved a "medical appraisal lawsuit." The reporter of Beiqing Daily was further informed that "she" involved not only civil compensation, but also criminal proceedings-Li, a frontline doctor who participated in postpartum treatment, was the suspect involved in the first "medical accident crime" in Fujian and was awaiting trial.
People in the medical field in Fujian Province told the reporter of Beiqing Daily that compared with the compensation amount of the deceased in the local medical accident, there is obviously a situation of "the same life with different prices" in the Chen Yanfang case: the compensation amount of her family is twice as high; Not counting the expenses paid by the hospital for the preservation of the remains. This statement was confirmed by Chen, the current president of Changle Hospital.
As for the reason why the remains continue to be preserved, some insiders in the hospital speculate that it is the weight left by family members and the government. Some experts in the industry believe that the cause of death is still unknown, which can also solve the autopsy needs. But either way, in the eyes of the industry, its "symbolic" significance is far better than the actual significance. According to the relevant regulations of forensic autopsy in China, the autopsy time is best within 7 days of death, otherwise it is difficult to determine the exact cause of death.
"After more than a week, the corpse cells will autolyse, which will seriously affect the autopsy conclusion. Especially for corpses involving medical activities, the object of judging the cause of death is mainly the cell formation under the microscope. If autolysis is almost impossible to judge, it is completely different from criminal autopsy or abnormal death autopsy! " Liu Ye, a Shanghai lawyer who has been engaged in forensic autopsy research for a long time, thinks.