Xiong Haizi's life is everywhere, and education is a major event for children's growth. Many parents pay for their children's mistakes just because they indulge and spoil their children. A girl from Guangxi, led by her parents, went to Audi 4S shop to see a new car. After entering the store, the couple were attracted by the vehicles and neglected to take care of the children.
It was this negligence that caused the children to scratch 10 new cars in the store, and the price of a car exceeded one million yuan. The girl's behavior brought trouble to both husband and wife. The manager of the 4S shop was distressed and angry when he saw the new car scratched. After finding the girl's parents, she explained the cause of the matter and asked the other party to compensate 200,000 yuan for the loss of new car paint.
Faced with such compensation, it is difficult for the girl's parents to accept it. They can bear the cost of repainting the new car, but they can't accept the compensation price of 200 thousand yuan proposed by 4S shop. I don't agree with the manager about the discount loss. Because the two sides could not reach an agreement, the manager was angry and took the couple to court.
The court made a judgment according to the relevant laws and the detailed course of the matter. As a result of the verdict, the girl's parents need to compensate the 4S shop for 70,000 yuan to scrape the vehicle. At this point, this matter has come to an end. Although it did not meet the expectations of the 4S store manager, the judgment also saved some losses for the 4S store. The legal basis is as follows:
According to Article 32 of the Tort Liability Law of People's Republic of China (PRC): "If a person without or with limited capacity for civil conduct causes damage to others, the guardian shall bear the tort liability. If a guardian fulfills his guardianship responsibility, his tort liability may be reduced. If a person without capacity for civil conduct or a person with limited capacity for civil conduct owns property and causes damage to others, he shall make compensation with his own property. The insufficient part is compensated by the guardian. "
This incident also shows how important children's education is. If the couple can look at their children in their eyes or hold them in their arms while watching the car, there will be no unpleasant situation afterwards.
Children are young and ignorant, and their behavior needs the restraint and education of parents. As guardians of children, we have not fulfilled our guardianship responsibilities and obligations and should pay for the mistakes made by children.
In this case, the couple are willing to pay for the mistakes made by their children, but they disagree on the amount of compensation. Both husband and wife think that they only need to bear the cost of repainting the vehicle, while the manager of 4S shop thinks that the repainting of the vehicle can not be regarded as a new car, which has a great impact on sales volume and price.
In the face of 4S shop's claim for compensation of 200,000 yuan, the court refused to support it. On the contrary, it adhered to the principle of objective facts and awarded the couple 70,000 yuan to make up for the losses caused to the 4S store. Although there is no need to compensate 200,000, it still loses 70,000 for no reason. Anyone who puts this situation up will feel sad.
I think the child will learn a profound lesson after this incident, and will not do anything to scratch the car again. Will you support the 4S store manager or the girl's parents in this matter?