Nanny abused the 85-year-old for a long time. After the exposure, she argued that "relaxing muscles and promoting blood circulation". Is it credible?

Nanny abused the 85-year-old man for a long time, and the pictures taken by the surveillance camera clearly showed that Nanny Zhang slapped, beat and even bit the old man, and recorded the beating pictures as high as 1 1 time. The evidence is conclusive and undeniable. Nanny Zhang should be investigated for criminal responsibility. As for the nanny, she later argued that it was for the elderly? Exercise muscles? 、? Just kidding? This kind of rhetoric is pure nonsense.

According to Liu's family, Liu is 85 years old. Because of Alzheimer's Harmo's disease, his consciousness is blurred and he can't communicate with people normally. Considering that the elderly can't take care of themselves, in March 2065438+2009, the family invited a nanny Zhang for him. Who knows, since then, the old man has been abused by Zhang many times!

At first, the family members didn't know, until once, when Grandpa Liu's granddaughter didn't want to watch the surveillance video, she found Zhang's abuse of the elderly.

In the video, Zhang repeatedly licked his ears, hit his abdomen, pushed and slapped the old man. Seeing this scene, the family of the old man was very angry and asked for a nanny for the old man. The purpose is to let the elderly enjoy their old age, but I didn't expect the elderly to be abused. In a rage, the family called the police.

After identification, Uncle Liu suffered minor contusions on his face, chest and elbows, with a cumulative area of 23 square centimeters and slight physical injuries.

On September 7, 2020, the case of nanny Zhang abusing Uncle Liu was heard in Fengtai Court.

During the trial, the prosecution believed that the defendant Zhang, as the caretaker of Uncle Liu, beat Uncle Liu more than ten times in more than a month, and the circumstances were very bad. Zhang should be investigated for criminal responsibility for abusing the ward.

Zhang tried to argue. She said that she got along well with the Liu family and respected Uncle Liu. Many actions in the video are actually normal actions when taking care of the elderly. Help the elderly? Exercise muscles? . For example, help the elderly to rub their arms and move their heads, but occasionally the movements may be biased.

Zhang said again, how about it? Do you usually play with him? ,? His stomach is upset. I'll rub it for him. Just say I hit him? Later, it was renamed? Some actions are really unintentional? . Until the judge showed the surveillance video in court, Zhang Cai admitted that he abused the elderly.

In this trial, the case was not pronounced in court. Zhang's defense lawyer demanded a lighter sentence. Do you think a light sentence should be given?