What did the lawyer say about the man who was killed by his girlfriend's ex-girlfriend but his girlfriend refused to appear in court?

Recently, @ Farmer, a user who lost his independence, published an article "Intern college students were brutally killed to save his girlfriend, and his girlfriend Zhu refused to testify in court", saying that "Zhu, a woman whose son protected her life, did not appear in court and refused to testify in court", which triggered a heated discussion among netizens.

This article was published by Hubei farmer Li, who claimed that the intern student who was brutally killed was his son, and his girlfriend Zhu refused to appear in court. Li said, "Zhu never showed up after the incident, but only communicated with me on QQ; Then she changed her mobile phone number, and we couldn't contact her at all. Before the trial, we applied for her to testify in court, and she refused. "

According to the contact information provided by Zhu, after the reporter dialed, the prompt was empty.

165438+1October 14, the case was heard in the Intermediate People's Court of Shijiazhuang City, and the verdict will be pronounced on another day.

According to the indictment provided by Li to the People's Procuratorate of Shijiazhuang City, "It was found out according to law that on March 27th, 1965, around 0/8, the defendant Wang Moujie took out a fruit knife from the window sill on the north side of his bedroom, threatened to hurt himself, and asked Zhu to tell his mobile phone password ... Li Junjie. Wang Mojie began to hit Li Junjie, then Wang Mojie took out a fruit knife and counted Li Junjie's face and neck ... Then 120 ambulance arrived at Yiling Hospital, and Li Junjie died after being rescued. "

The autopsy opinion issued by the police showed: "Li Junjie died of hemorrhagic shock caused by others cutting neck blood vessels with sharp instruments."

Qin Chunhui, a civil litigation attorney of the Affiliated High School and a lawyer of Hebei Chongye Law Firm, expressed different views to Red Star News.

First of all, criminal cases attach importance to facts, and the evidence chain in this case is relatively complete. The procuratorate also prosecuted for intentional homicide. "It should be considered that Zhu has the moral obligation to testify in court, but in fact whether she appears in court has little influence on the judgment, and not appearing in court is also in line with the practice of previous judicial trials."

The search found that the low attendance rate of witnesses in criminal cases in China was once concerned by the Supreme People's Court. A court in Shandong analyzed 4 1 1 criminal cases concluded in 20 13 years, and there were 3 cases in which witnesses appeared in court, accounting for only 0.7% of all cases.

Lawyer Qin Chunhui told Red Star News that although Zhu refused to appear in court, she still provided witness testimony. When he was reading the newspaper, he read the police interrogation record of Zhu. "No problem." For these materials, Qin said that the case is still under trial and there is no judgment yet, so it cannot be made public for the time being.

In the chat record with Zhu provided by Li, Zhu once said: "My parents must have given priority to protecting me when this happened, so they didn't come forward in time to give you a truth and forgive me."

Li said that he has two wishes now. First, many parties appealed that the court could immediately sentence the murderer to death and give his son an explanation. Second, I hope Zhu Can will stand up and face himself. "At least let me know what it's like when my son is gone."