Lawyers don't give it, and the reasons for not giving it are useless.
First of all, it is wrong for the court not to serve the judgment on the close relatives of the parties. However, if the court is not clear about the delivery or contact information of close relatives, the court will generally deliver an additional judgment to the lawyer and ask the lawyer to hand it over.
Second, the lawyer does not give the judgment to the close relatives of the parties, depending on what the situation is. If the client is not a close relative of the client, the lawyer may not give it to the close relative, but the lawyer shall provide the client with the original or copy of the judgment; If the client is a close relative, the lawyer shall provide the close relative with the original or copy of the judgment.
Third, the lawyer said that the judgment was useless to close relatives, which was irresponsible. The judgment declares the future fate of the parties. How can it be said that it is useless? Especially when the parties "don't know the true face of Lushan Mountain and live in but toward which corner of the mountain", close relatives may be able to objectively analyze the case and find the best solution. If a lawyer refuses to give a judgment to a close relative, it can only prove that the lawyer already thinks that the judgment result is the best result, and there is no need to appeal, even if it is appealed, it will not change anything. This kind of handling by lawyers is also inappropriate.
What should the family do?
Generally speaking, when a criminal case is judged, the judgment will be handed over to the parties or agents. If a family member needs a judgment, it can be handled in the following ways:
1, close relatives come to the court to ask the original judge for a copy of the judgment with the proof of kinship or household registration book. The judge can call out the judgment from the file and affix the official seal of the court after copying, which has the same effect as the original judgment.
Generally, the agent in this case has a written judgment, and he can make a copy to his relatives.
3. The judgment can be found online, downloaded and printed.
Prisoners usually have the original verdict in their hands. If they are lost, the original sentence is in the prison file. Prisoners or close relatives can apply for copying the judgment, and the prison will generally agree.
In addition to hiring a lawyer, there are several ways to get a judgment.
First contact the judge and ask the judge to make a judgment. Since the legal provisions can be served on the defendant's family, there is generally no problem for the defendant's family to ask the court for a judgment.
Second, now that the court judgment documents are online, you can publicly search the corresponding cases from the judgment documents online.
Third, after the judgment takes effect according to the regulations, it should also be delivered to the defendant's unit or the local police station or the registration authority of the defendant's unit. You can also ask the local police station if there is a verdict.
Is it appropriate for lawyers not to give scanned copies or copies of family judgments? Not appropriate. Family members, as clients, entrusted lawyers to defend the defendant. Of course, they want to have a full understanding of the outcome of the case, how to determine the facts and evidence of the court, whether the reasons for the judgment are sufficient, and whether the case needs to be appealed or appealed. These can only be seen through the judgment. Therefore, the lawyer said that it is useless to refuse inappropriately!
The reason why the law excludes family members is because the age of criminal responsibility stipulated by Chinese law is 14 years old. For the defendant who committed a crime under the age of 18, the law stipulates that the judgment should be served on adult relatives. /kloc-Defendants over 0/8 years of age are persons with full capacity for civil liability in civil matters. As the saying goes, if a person does something, the court will definitely not send the judgment to his family.