trial site
Kaifeng City People's Procuratorate accused the defendants Liu Qingyi and Liu Dejian of intentionally hurting others, resulting in serious consequences of one person's death, and should be investigated for criminal responsibility for intentional injury.
trial site
During the trial, the public prosecution agency produced relevant evidence, and the plaintiff in the incidental civil action produced relevant medical bills and other evidence at the request of the incidental civil action; Defendants Liu Qingyi and Liu Dejian, their defenders, plaintiffs in incidental civil action and their agents ad litem conducted cross-examination, and both the prosecution and the defense fully expressed their opinions under the auspices of the court. Defendants Liu Qingyi and Liu Dejian made their final statements.
trial site
NPC deputies, CPPCC members, journalists, defendants and relatives of victims attended the trial. In view of the great concern from all walks of life about this case, the court announced that it would pronounce sentences regularly.
Previously, on February 8, 65438, the joint investigation team of Ye Mouqing case in Qixian County issued the "Explanation on the Relevant Situation of Ye Mouqing Case in Qianying Village, Banmu Township, Qixian County". The full text is as follows.
In view of the recent public concern about the case of Ye Mouqing in Qianying Village, Banmu Township, our county set up a joint investigation team to investigate according to law. The relevant situation is now explained as follows:
I. Basic information and progress of the case
At about 9 o'clock on June 28th, 20265438/KLOC-0, Ye Mouqing, a villager from Qianying Village, Banmu Township, Qixian County, had an argument with Liu Mouyi and Liu Moujian while drinking in their hometown "Peasant Banquet" restaurant, which led to a fight and was later persuaded by others. At about 23 o'clock, Ye Mouqing felt unwell after returning home, and his family took him to the hospital. On July 7, Ye Mouqing died after medical treatment. At 2: 36 on June 29th, 20021year, Qixian Public Security Bureau received an alarm from Ye Mouqing's family and filed a case for investigation on the same day. The suspect involved in the case, Liu Mouyi, was detained in criminal detention and detained in Qixian detention center. At present, the investigation of this case has ended, and the Kaifeng Municipal People's Procuratorate has filed a public prosecution with the Kaifeng Intermediate People's Court in accordance with legal procedures, and the case is under trial.
Two. Investigation on the problems reflected by the families of the deceased
The family members of the deceased raised questions such as "Liu Mouyan participated in the beating but got away with it", "Houtang village party secretary participated in the beating, which was not handled by the public security organs" and "whether the murder weapon was used in the case was not included in the investigation". The joint investigation team checked and compared the surrounding surveillance video, witness testimony, judicial expertise documents and other relevant evidence, and found that the problems reflected were untrue.
Third, about the disappearance of Ye, the daughter of the deceased.
After the case occurred, the county public security organs communicated with the families of the deceased many times to introduce the progress of the case and explain the laws and regulations. During the normal handling of the case, Ye, Ye, Ye Moling and other family members of the deceased distorted the facts and continued to publish false statements such as "the murderer is at large" and "Ye lost contact" on online social media, misleading public opinion and adversely affecting the normal handling of the case. On February 6, 2022, in front of Ye's boyfriend, the police of the county public security bureau showed their certificates and brought them back to the investigation according to law.
Related reports:
Media: Henan girls cry for their dead father. I believe the official statement is not indifference.
Recently, the case of Ye Mouqing in Qixian County caused an uproar.
A year and a half ago, Ye Mouqing, a villager from Qixian County, Henan Province, was invited to attend the banquet. Who knows that during the dinner, Ye Mouqing had a fight with Liu Mouyi and Liu Moujian who went to the meeting together.
After the beating, Ye Mouqing was taken to hospital by his family and died nine days later. The day after the beating, the police arrested Liu Mouyi and Liu Moujian and detained them in criminal detention.
Police notice
A year later, Ye Moting, the daughter of the deceased Ye Mouqing, suddenly voiced on the Internet, saying that "there is nowhere to go, and she has been wandering outside for more than a year" and "there is no way to go".
In the report letter, a message was mentioned-the murderer Liu Mouyan is still at large.
Who is Liu Mouyan? The public has speculated. What is even more bizarre is that on February 6, 65438, the reporter Ye was suddenly exposed and lost contact, which pushed the public opinion to a climax.
On the evening of February 8, 65438, Qixian County, standing at the forefront, issued a statement in the name of the joint investigation team of Yemouqing case in Qixian County. The crisis of confidence has not been lifted.
0 1
Tears of the deceased's family
On February 6, 65438, the topic # Girl reported that her father was beaten and lost contact # boarded the hot search. There is a "Looking for You" circulating on the Internet, saying that Ye was "taken away by seven or eight men in Qixian County and forcibly taken away".
Ye, the daughter of the deceased Ye Mouqing, has been reporting that Liu Mouyan, the murderer of her father, is at large.
On the evening of February 8, 65438, it was suspected that Ye's family took her home, which aroused the anger of netizens. The video shows that one girl's eyes are frightened and the other two women are kneeling on the street crying for the land. The situation is very tragic.
Video screenshot
Many people are asking: What happened to Ye at the police station? Is Liu Mouyan a murderer on the run? Is there any shady behind this beating death case?
On the night of Ye's return home, the joint investigation team of Ye Mouqing case in Qixian issued a statement, and the basic situation of the case was consistent with 202 1 notified by the police in July.
According to the statement, the joint investigation team checked and compared the surrounding surveillance videos, witness testimonies, judicial expertise documents and other relevant evidence, and found that the problems reflected were untrue.
Regarding the fact that Ye was taken away for investigation, the statement said that during the normal handling of the case, Ye, Ye Moling and other family members of the deceased distorted the facts and continued to publish false statements such as "the murderer is at large" and "Ye lost contact" on online social media, misleading public opinion and adversely affecting the normal handling of the case. On February 6, 2022, in front of Ye's boyfriend, the police of the county public security bureau showed their certificates and brought them back to the investigation according to law.
There are serious differences between the two sides about whether Liu Mouyan participated in the beating. The family of the deceased insisted that he was the "murderer", while the joint investigation team believed that the family of the deceased was distorting the facts.
The internet almost overwhelmingly supports the families of the deceased.
02
I believe that the official statement is not indifference.
Of course, the families of the deceased deserve sympathy. Generally speaking, the police report and the statement of the joint investigation team are more credible. At this point, we should trust the official investigation.
First of all, Liu Moyan is an employee like the other two who have been prosecuted. There is no actual evidence for the comments about gangsters on the Internet.
Secondly, Ye Mouqing's case is not a case in a vacuum, and it is supported by relevant evidence such as surrounding surveillance videos, witness testimony and judicial expertise documents. If the family of the deceased can provide conclusive evidence that Liu Mouyan participated in the beating, Liu Mouyan is unlikely to escape the net.
What many people ignore is that the cost of official lying is much higher than that of individual lying, which is true of any public opinion event.
Believe in the official, the probability of obtaining correct information is always greater.
The real name report of the family of the deceased is intended to use public opinion to put pressure on the police, or to re-investigate or promote the process of handling cases. In order to win the support of public opinion and interest, the statement may not be objective. As a third party, the joint investigation team is unlikely to take sides. Especially in public notification and statement, once the information given is proved to be wrong, it will inevitably lead to the loss of credibility, and the members of the investigation team may also face relevant penalties. Being wise, they have no motivation to do so.
03
The official statement is vague.
Why is the official often the weak and untrustworthy side of the public opinion field?
Reality and the field of public opinion are reversed. How strong the public security department is in reality is how weak it is in front of public opinion. Once public opinion occurs, it is often in a passive position and does not grasp the opportunity. More importantly, the statement of the joint investigation team of Ye Mouqing case in Qixian County is also vague and easy to be caught.
For example, Ye Mouqing has been killed for a year and a half. Some lawyers pointed out that in the Criminal Procedure Law, the normal time limit of public prosecution law, including investigation, prosecution by procuratorate and court trial, is only 200 days. This case has dragged on for a year and a half, and it really needs to be explained to the victims' families and the public.
For another example, Ye was taken to the police station for investigation. What is the reason? What did he experience during the investigation? There should be a clearer and more formal statement, otherwise it will easily lead to bad guesses such as "covering your mouth" and "revenge".
In the basic information of the case, we should trust the official statement more, and don't be influenced by online emotions. At this time, the investigation team should also calmly face the doubts, give a reasonable explanation, and dispel the doubts in the public's mind.