According to Phoenix. com. Com, lawyer Chen Shifeng asked Jiangge's mother three questions after the adjournment.
First, did Jiangge mention the reason why Liu Xin went home together?
Second, what is Liu Xin afraid of?
Third, is Jiangge unwilling to live with Liu Xin?
I don't know whether Sherlock Holmes or Conan said that it is true to rule out all the impossibilities, even if the rest are impossible. Since I have never handled a criminal case, I can only extract my own thoughts and analysis from the suspense mystery novels and legal film and television works I perceive:
1
Q: Did Jiangge mention the reason why Liu Xin went home together?
A: Liu Xin told Jiangge on WeChat that I was afraid. Wait for me at the station.
Analysis:
Before the trial, the prosecutor and the defense lawyer must have been familiar with all the evidence, including Jiang Ge's mobile phone, which had a chat record with Jiang Mu, so the defense lawyer knew the answer before asking questions, so his focus was not on how to smooth out the facts, but on how to use the facts to pave the way for shifting the focus.
2
Q: What is Liu Xin afraid of?
A: I don't know.
Analysis:
The problem ahead is paving the way, and this problem is already very direct. In my opinion, the answer to this question can only bring three possibilities:
First, fear of Chen Shifeng. Chen Shifeng as a defendant, any evidence pointing to him may be the key to conviction. On the contrary, any evidence that does not point to him may point to someone else. As Chen's defender, it is impossible to lead the evidence against him. Therefore, this description of fear without a clear target can turn Chen Cong from a focus card into a counter-push card. Although they are all passive, there is already one more choice.
Second, I'm afraid of Jiangge. This is plan B in the process of criminal case defense, which is common in the United States. When the client can't get rid of the crime through the original defense scheme, he shifts the focus of the contradiction to an unlikely (impossible) witness, so that he has new reasonable doubts and the client can get rid of the crime. Because of the particularity of our judicial system, no one has ever seen such an operation. In this case, Jiangge was taken as the object of fear to implement Plan B, but it was excluded because of the facts of Jiang and Liu.
Third, fear of the third person. Without specifying the specific object, anyone outside the case may extend the fear of this kind of thing from Chen to others at the time of the crime, weakening the love-hate entanglement between Chen and Liu and weakening the causal relationship between the passion of breaking up and killing. Others are more likely, and their own possibility is lower, so the possibility of final conviction is less.
Through these three possibilities, Chen's lawyer has begun to shift his focus.
three
Q: Is Jiangge unwilling to live with Liu Xin?
A: Brother Jiang said that Liu Xin didn't buy daily necessities, cook or clean, and even I threw away the garbage. So I don't want to live with her.
Analysis:
On the one hand, if Liu Xin is the object of Plan B, then Jiangge's mother's answer is exactly what she wants. The living habits of the two sides are different, which makes them unwilling to live together. Lawyer Chen can easily draw a picture of a pair of classmates who often quarrel or even fight by asking if he knows their quarrel and will tell you. If the focus shifts, Chen naturally wants to go to court.
On the other hand, even if you don't accept Plan B, the difference and contrast of living habits before testifying in court in Liu Xin can weaken Liu Xin's own persuasiveness and probative power to some extent, and make a breakthrough when you testify in Liu Xin, which can be said to be beneficial and harmless.
Besides, apart from these three questions, whether Liu Xin and Chen Shifeng make a clean break has not been confirmed. In addition, the assumption mentioned above (I have to testify in court at the thought of Liu Xin's fickleness) is creepy. I hope there will be no mistakes in the trial.
The above is the original text, updated on the third day, and Liu Xin really changed her testimony. The prosecution wants to convict Chen through Liu Xin, and Chen wants to use Liu to get away with it-expecting the prosecution to continue to exert its strength.