According to "Wei Zhi Ming Di Ji", in the first month of the third year of King Jing, "the emperor died in Jiafutang at the age of 36". If we push from the third year of Jing to the thirty-sixth year, our birth year should be nine years of Jian 'an, but Cao Pi's chastity is also August of Jian 'an. How did Zhen Shi give birth to Ming Di? If Cao Pi was really born, it should be ten years since Jian 'an. Pei Songzhi once said: "Wei Wu decided to take power in August of the ninth year of Jian 'an, and after Emperor Wen's enlistment, Ming Di should have been born in the first month of this year, that is, thirty-four years. At that time, the new moon will be corrected and December of the previous year will be the first month of this year, which may be thirty-five years, but not thirty-six. Neighbor Mao Heting's Jiuzhai Diary therefore said, "It's Yuan's blood." . "Lu Bi's Collection of Records of the Three Kingdoms also said:" Stealing the article about Cheng Zuo (Chen Shou) is really a song. Those who read history can infer the year and month to prove that Mrs. Zhen gave her death. Wei can't be an heir for a long time, so it goes without saying whose son (Cao Yu) is. "
What Lu means is that he knows that he should be thirty-five, but now he writes "thirty-six", which is deliberately implying to readers that he is a descendant of the Yuan family.
Mr. Mao Heting is a famous scholar in modern times, and Lu Bi, the author of Records of the Three Kingdoms, enjoys a high reputation in the academic circles of the Three Kingdoms. Both of them think that it is not Cao Pi's own son, but the son of Zhen Shi's ex-husband, Yuan, and their judgment is obviously authoritative. However, because there is not enough historical data to support this view, it is not conclusive. In the final analysis, it's just a "family statement." Teacher Jin also mentioned another point at the end of the article.
For the convenience of readers, the following excerpts are as follows:
Lu Kan-ru's "Year of the Department of Medieval Literature" determined that Cao Pi-nian was the eleventh year of Jian 'an (AD 206), and the year of his death was still the third year of Jing (AD 239), at the age of 34. That is to say, xelloss sent me to live. Thirty-six plans are the best policy, and there is no deep meaning.
As for what kind of views Mr. Jin agrees with, since it is not clearly put forward in the article, later scholars naturally dare not speculate. Judging from the title of the article "The Mystery of Wei Mingdi's Biological Father", it may be that this issue is inconclusive and needs to be doubted.
However, after textual research, Mao and Lu's theory seems reasonable, but in fact it is groundless and has a lot of speculative elements. In fact, as long as we carefully study the relevant original text of The Romance of Three Kingdoms and Pei's notes, it is not difficult to draw the conclusion that "Cao is not as good as Fei Di".
According to "Wei Zhi Ming Di Ji", Ming Taizu sealed the bell as a character, and Wendi was also a prince. His innate love for Mao often makes him find both ends meet. Fifteen years, Feng Wude Gong. In the second year, he was Qi Huangong, and in the third year, he was the King of the Plain.
If it is assumed that Ding Hai was thirty-six years old when he died in the first month of Cao Pi 'an, the following chronology will be obtained after backward calculation:
In the eighth year of Jian 'an (AD 203), Cao was born in Zhenguan.
In the twenty-second year of Jian 'an (AD 2 17), Cao Pi was named Wudehou at the age of five.
In the second year of Huang Chu (AD 22 1), Cao Pi was made King of Qi at the age of nine.
In the year of Huang San (AD 222), Cao Pi, who was only ten years old, was made King of the Plain.
In the third year of Jing (AD 239), Cao Pi died at the age of sixteen.
May wish to refer to the May Fifth Tone about Cao Pi's "Wei Zhi Wendi Ji". The son of heaven ordered the king to chase Mao, his wife, Shi Ding, the queen and the prince, so as to cover the Duke of Wu.
Cao Pi succeeded to the throne, and the twenty-five-year reconstruction of An was the first year of Yankang. This year 1 1 month, he forced Emperor Xian of Han to meditate and change to Huang Chu. Therefore, the twenty-five years of Jian 'an, the first year of Yankang and the first year of Huang Chu were actually the same year, that is, Xelloss was in the first year of Huang Chu (AD 220), when Xelloss was five years old.
However, according to the chronology of Cao Pi's death at the age of 16, it is shown that he was named Wudehou in the 22nd year of Jian 'an (AD 2 17), which is three years less than the record in Wei Zhi Wendi Ji. Is Wei Zhi Wendy mistaken?
In the twenty-second year of Jian 'an, Cao Cao, as Wang Wei, has not died yet. Prince xelloss has no knighthood, and even xelloss has no title, except for the official worship of the corps commander with five senses. Then his son Cao Beihuan was sent to Wang Wei by the emperor. On the contrary, it would be false if Cao Pi succeeded to the throne in the first year of Yankang.
According to "Wei Zhi Wendi Collection", Cao Pi was between May of the 10th year of Jian 'an and May of the 11th year of Jian 'an (in May of the first year of Huang Chu, he was named Wudehou when he was fifteen years old, and his date of birth must be before May of the 11th year of Jian 'an). Even if the limit value is calculated, Zhen Shi's pregnancy time should be July in the ninth year of Jian 'an, and in May of this year, Cao Cao had besieged Yecheng, and Yuan was here at this time.
At this point, it is not difficult to draw a conclusion that Cao Ben's theory of scampering around the age of sixteen is absolutely difficult to establish, not to mention what happened after Cao Pi's family.
Although Cao Ba Laohuili is good at writing 5, there is still a question-why did Ji write Cao Ben as a 16-year-old woman? Did Chen Shou do something wrong with such a simple arithmetic problem? Before answering this question, it is necessary to mention Mr. Lu Kanru's point of view.
Mr. Lu Kanru, mentioned by Mr. Jin at the end of the article, is a famous master of Chinese studies, so-called "the theory of various schools." Although I don't know how Mr. Lu is defined, the year of Cao Pi is probably the eleventh year of Jian 'an, which is also calculated according to the records in Wei Zhi Wendi Ji. But it is debatable that Mr. Lu bewitched Cao Bei at the age of fourteen.
Because Cao Pi was born in the first month of this year, but the specific time is Ding Hai. If Cao Pi was born in the eleventh year of Jian 'an and his birthday was not in the first month, he should have been only thirty-three years old when he died. What needs to be clear is that this 33-year-old refers to 33 years old, which means that he was born in Jian 'an No.11 Middle School. (Actually, it was because Cao Bijing changed March to April in the first year of Jingchu, according to the performance of a company, "We thought that Wei wanted to unify the land, and it was appropriate to build the ugly month as the first month", and Cao Fang, who acceded to the throne, changed the calendar back. So the month of his death, if calculated according to the previous calendar, should actually be1February. )
Therefore, when calculating the year of Cao Pi's death, it is inappropriate to count Jing three years as one year old and Mr. Lu Kanru as 34 years old, which obviously includes 239 years. If you don't count AD 239, Cao Ben is thirteen years old.
If Cao Haoran was born between February and May in the 11th year of Jian 'an, then it is bold to guess that because the first stroke of "three" is a horizontal line, it is very likely to be mistaken for "one point", the second stroke is the same as the second stroke of "six", and the third stroke is a horizontal line, or it may be mistaken for "two points". In other words, the so-called "36 years" is probably the mistake of "33 years". The ancients mistakenly copied "33 years" into "36 years", which may be the reason why Cao Pi is stupid.