On August 13, the People's Court of Nantong Economic and Technological Development Zone held a public hearing and pronounced the case of Shangshang v. Rudong Civil Affairs Bureau. The judgment revoked the defendant Rudong Civil Affairs Bureau's refusal to correct the wrong reply, confirmed that Shang Shang's marriage registration with the third person Shen Moumou in Rudong Civil Affairs Bureau was invalid, and deleted the wrong marriage registration information. This result is good news for her, but there is still one place in five places where the marriage registration has not been revoked and it is still in a "married state". Now that she has become a mother, the real marriage certificate is still out of reach for her.
Five "black marriages" are like uneven scars.
The 38-year-old Shang gave birth to a son in July this year and is currently in the second month. Speaking of the nine months' experience, she was exhausted. "I am very happy to get the license. It is really inexplicable to encounter such a thing! " I don't want to be married five times. It was a black history, like a bumpy scar! "
Shang Shang and her boyfriend Wang Xin (a pseudonym) fell in love for more than ten years and finally decided to get married. On the morning of 20 19 12 10, she and her boyfriend came to the marriage registration office of the civil affairs bureau of Yicheng District, Zhumadian City, Henan Province to register their marriage. After handing over the ID card to the staff, she was told that she could not go through the registration formalities because she had registered marriage with five men in the system and they were all in a "normal marriage state" at present.
The system shows that Shang Shang has registered marriage with five men.
Hearing the staff's reply, Shang Shang and her boyfriend were blinded on the spot. "Don't you know I've never been married?" The staff said that they had seen many such marriages before, but denied them. "Their attitude is that I am lying. What's more, they think I'm cheating on my marriage. " The comments from people around him made Shang Shang breathless.
"They advised my boyfriend that if he got a license with me again, I would get married six times." But Wang Xin firmly believes that she and Shang Shang have known each other for more than ten years and have never seen her having an affair with other men. She can't register for marriage. Wang Xin tried to suppress his emotions: "We have known each other for more than ten years, and we all know each other very well. She can't marry anyone else. I must know what is going on. "
The staff of the marriage registration office repeatedly confirmed and entered the still existing ID number, and the computer system automatically associated her marriage registration information with five men, namely:
21September 26th, 2004 and Mengshan East
5438+065438+June 2, 2004 with Du in Hebei.
June 5438+February 65438+July 2004 King of Hebei.
On June 23, 2005, Yinmou, the first in Anhui.
July 2005 19 and Shen Moumou were in Rudong, Jiangsu.
These five marriage registration information are concentrated between 2004 and 2005. Shang Shang told reporters that she has been unemployed at home for two years, has never traveled far, and has never lost her identity card. She doesn't know any of these five people. "The staff said that in order to thoroughly find out, only the civil affairs bureau where these five people are registered can find detailed information." ?
The staff inquired about the marriage registration information.
In order to find out the reason, Shang Shang and Wang Xin went to the marriage registration office of jieshou city Civil Affairs Bureau, Anhui Province, and the staff reconfirmed Shang Shang's five pieces of marriage registration information after inquiry. "There are signatures, fingerprints and photos on the marriage registration form, and the staff of the Civil Affairs Bureau recognized it at a glance." However, the staff said that Shang Shang used the first-generation ID card with 15 digits when registering for marriage, while Shang Shang now uses the second-generation ID card with 18 digits, which is related to Shang Shang's marriage registration information. The staff said that the two people are still different, which is probably caused by the duplication of 15 ID cards. They can't get rid of the marriage registration information.
Shang Shang went to jieshou city Civil Affairs Bureau to inquire about marriage registration information.
The staff also said: "The marriage certificate here is not fake, but in 2005, the internal system of civil affairs was not connected to the whole country. How do we know what it looks like? We can't find out if she changed the photo. The two of them got married voluntarily. " The staff said that they had done their duty and they could not verify the authenticity of the documents. Suggest calling the police.
After safeguarding rights, the three places revoked her marriage registration.
Shang Shang and her boyfriend were running around in the Civil Affairs Bureau when she accidentally found out that she was pregnant for two months. In order to get a birth certificate for the child, she asked the Civil Affairs Bureau if she could get a marriage certificate first. The staff replied: "You are still married. If we help you deal with it, it is bigamy. "
Since then, the civil affairs departments of the five places are still required to cancel the relevant false marriage registration information, on the grounds that others used their identity to register their marriage, which made it impossible for them to register their marriage. After being rejected, she reported the case to the public security organ.
Shang Shang told Niu Zi journalist that after reporting the case, some progress has been made.
Hebei public security organs issued a document to the Civil Affairs Bureau, which directly revoked the marriage registration information of Shang Shang and Wang Du.
Due to the death of Yin, jieshou city, Anhui Province, Jieshou Court ruled that Shang Shang's marriage registration was invalid;
Shandong Zoucheng Court rejected Shang Shang's claim on the grounds that it had exceeded the statutory time limit for prosecution.
Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau replied that there is still no revocation authority.
Shang Shang appealed to the court of Nantong Economic and Technological Development Zone to cancel the marriage registration with Shen Moumou made by Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau on July 19, 2005.
Shang Shang said that in fact, she does not intend to sue, because it takes a long time to file a case, review and open a court. "I am bent on getting a marriage certificate before the baby is born. I think it is best for the Civil Affairs Bureau to help me cancel the marriage registration information through communication, but after a month of communication, I can only sue without results. "
Shang Shang used to be a salesman, and the end of the year is the busiest time. In order to keep up with the situation, I have to resign. In order to save money, she learned to write her own indictment and was in a state of anxiety every day. "The doctor said that I am pregnant at this age and am an elderly woman. Running around is emotionally unstable and is very bad for your baby. " The judge of Nantong Economic and Technological Development Zone Court suggested that she could file a case online and avoid running away. "Now only my boyfriend is working alone to support family expenses. We have mortgages and car loans, and there is really no extra money to ask a lawyer. " Shang Shang recalled those days and said, "I am really wronged. I am exhausted from hitting the wall again and again! "
A Jiangsu man, who has been married five times, is still married to her and is suspected of being cheated.
After accepting the case, Huang Jinhui, president of the administrative court of Nantong Development Zone Court, immediately went to Rudong to investigate Shen Moumou, his family and neighbors. Huang Jinhui told reporters that they took photos of Shang Shang in 2005 and 20 19 to identify Shen Moumou, who immediately said that he didn't know Shang Shang. Huang Jinhui found Shen's family and neighbors to verify, and they agreed that Shangshang in the photo was not an impostor who married Shen in 2005.
Shen Moumou said that the woman who married herself had long since disappeared. At that time, Shen met a friend in a vegetable market in Nantong. His friend introduced him to a woman from Henan who had a brother with a disabled leg. Not long after, Shen Moumou talked about marriage with the woman. "Her brother paid a bride price of 1 10,000 yuan." Shen did not hesitate to agree. Two or three weeks after the marriage registration, Shen told his new wife that she could move her household registration, and her wife readily agreed.
On the way back to Henan with my brother-in-law to help my wife move her account, my brother-in-law with a disabled leg actually ran away in the service area. Shen got a call from home saying that his new wife had also run away. Shen Moumou went to the police station to report the missing population. The police replied that the identity information was correct, but the photo was wrong and the identity card was forged. On 20 10, Shen found a new girlfriend to get married, so he went to Rudong court to get a divorce judgment. He registered his marriage in the marriage registry with a divorce judgment.
Nantong local court ordered the Civil Affairs Bureau to delete the wrong registration.
The reporter learned from the court of Nantong Economic and Technological Development Zone that the court held that the case was registered in the name of others. For example, Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau registered Shang as a marriage party without its knowledge, which is obviously illegal and an invalid administrative act. The still existing "marriage history" still exists in the national marriage registration system. This invalid act continues to infringe on the independent and legitimate rights and interests of both parties to the marriage, and is still applying to Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau for cancellation. Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau, as the registration authority, should fulfill the obligation of error correction and take the initiative to remedy according to law, instead of letting the wrong information exist on the grounds that it has no authority.
Nantong Development Zone Court held an online session and pronounced a sentence in court. The judgment revoked the defendant Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau's refusal to correct the wrong reply, and confirmed that the marriage registration handled by the plaintiff and the third person Shen Moumou in Rudong County Civil Affairs Bureau was invalid. The defendant deleted the plaintiff's wrong marriage registration information within 60 days from the effective date of the judgment. Winning the case is good news, but it is still difficult to get a marriage certificate.
After the verdict was pronounced in the first instance, Shang Shang thanked the judge online through the Zhiyun trial system and said: "This incident has seriously affected my normal life, and now the court has finally helped me solve the problem!"
Shang Shang told Niu Zi journalist: "When I was desperate, this judgment gave me a glimmer of hope, and the court also took the initiative to help me find legal aid. I am very grateful to them. But I still can't get a marriage certificate. Now my marital status is still in the Civil Affairs Bureau of Shandong, and only the marriage registration information there can be eliminated, but the court there rejected it on the grounds that it exceeded the statutory time limit for prosecution. "
"Now that the babies are born, we haven't got a marriage certificate yet. Without a marriage certificate, we can't get a birth certificate and a birth certificate, and our children can't stay at home. " Shang Shang said that the birth of a child has maternity insurance, and the expenses of hospitalization can be reimbursed. Without a marriage certificate, I can't apply now.
"Our village has a policy that every newborn has a subsidy of 6,000 yuan, but there must be a marriage certificate and a birth permit, but I don't have these." In order to get a birth certificate for their children, they went to Zhengzhou last week and spent several thousand yuan on paternity testing. They can't get the child's birth certificate until the paternity test results come out.
"Fortunately, my family has always supported me and they have always encouraged me. Take your time and things will work out. " Shang Shang said that she recently wrote a letter of complaint to the relevant departments, hoping to solve the matter as soon as possible, but the result was to let her wait for the result.
When can Shang Shang's last "marriage registration" be corrected? When can she get a real marriage certificate? Like her, we are looking forward to it.