On 20 12 1 65438+10/month12, Wang, her husband, received the notice of appraisal conclusion from Lanshan Branch of Linyi Public Security Bureau, and hired relevant personnel to appraise zhangyan's mental state and criminal responsibility when he committed the crime. The appraisal conclusion was "1,acute transient psychosis; 2. No criminal responsibility. " Wang was shocked-"zhangyan succeeded in pretending to be crazy."
2012165438+10 month 19, in a fit of pique, Wang found Xinmin weekly, counted the doubts and sought public support. On the other hand, Uncle Zhang Guoqiang, a family member of zhangyan who has never been interviewed by any media after the incident (using a pseudonym at the request of the interviewee), also accepted an exclusive interview with Xinmin Weekly for the first time, responding and clarifying all previous rumors one by one, and citing a large number of facts to prove that zhangyan was really in a state of mental illness at the time of the incident.
The family provided a "shocking" inside story about zhangyan's abnormality before his murder and the possible causes of his mental disorder. After May, can the truth be clarified?
After the accident, zhangyan was criminally detained by the police on suspicion of "endangering public security by dangerous means". The victim's husband, Wang, revealed that after zhangyan was detained, zhangyan's family asked for a psychiatric appraisal. On August 9th, zhangyan's family sent the materials for reference. Wang Le once protested that this video was clearly recorded. "She is pretending to be crazy, and identification will only delay time and only make the murderer linger." The police finally agreed to the request of zhangyan's family in accordance with the law and entrusted the Judicial Appraisal Institute of Qingdao Mental Health Center to appraise zhangyan's mental state and criminal responsibility at the time of the crime. Wang also accepted it. "I think she (zhangyan) may indeed have this right. My only expectation is that the appraisal conclusion can be fair and equitable. "
201211kloc-0/2 The Interpol Brigade of Lanshan Branch informed Wang to receive the notice of appraisal conclusion. Wang was stunned when he saw the conclusion of "acute transient psychosis" and "no criminal responsibility". "This is unacceptable. I can only say that she pretended to be crazy after killing and the initial installation was successful. " Wang has applied to the more advanced and authoritative judicial expertise centers in Beijing and Shanghai for re-appraisal of zhangyan's mental state.
The reporter consulted Xie Bin, deputy director of Shanghai Mental Health Center and member of Shanghai Expert Committee for Judicial Appraisal of Mental Illness. He explained that acute transient psychosis is a kind of severe psychosis, but its onset is more urgent and the course of disease is shorter than that of chronic psychosis such as schizophrenia. The short course may be several weeks, and the long course may be several months. As for the causes of acute transient psychosis, Xie Bin explained that the causes of psychosis are very complicated and it is difficult for the medical community to explain clearly. However, if the stimulation of a car accident does not necessarily lead to acute transient psychosis, there are clear incentives, such as stimulation leading to psychosis. Most of them are psychogenic and post-traumatic stress disorder. Because he didn't know much about the case, Xie Bin couldn't make a definite judgment on zhangyan's condition, but he concluded that if zhangyan was identified as acute transient psychosis, the accident was probably related to this kind of psychosis. "In other words, the disease is ahead and the car accident is behind."
Wang does not know the professional knowledge of "acute transient psychosis". "Zhang Yan is an expert in this field, and she knows it." He insisted that zhangyan was an expert in mental illness, and said that he had gone to zhangyan students, who all testified that zhangyan had taught this course. "About a week after the incident, zhangyan's uncle personally told my mother that his niece was a teacher of psychiatry. He wants to express that her niece is of high quality, will not do immoral things for no reason, and has no intention of exposing her professional background. "
Since the police only gave Wang a psychiatric appraisal conclusion paper, the content was limited to this conclusion. Wang Le asked the police for a complete appraisal report issued by the appraisal center. "I want to see the basis for making such a conclusion." According to the police, the attachment has more than 20 pages, but according to the law, it cannot be copied or even read. "What legal provisions?" Wang was puzzled and questioned himself.
Wang insisted that zhangyan's spirit had been normal before the incident. The two families have lived in the same community for more than ten years, and zhangyan has always given people the impression of high quality and culture. "Although we don't know her very well, the basic situation is clear. Moreover, after the incident, we visited a large number of people, and no one reported that her spirit had been abnormal. "
Wang raised two "doubts" about this appraisal conclusion. One is 10. On June 26th, because the appraisal conclusion was delayed, Wang Jia and CCTV reporters went to the forensic appraisal office of Qingdao Mental Health Center to urge, "But zhangyan's family actually knew for the first time that the reporter was interviewing at the appraisal center. How do they know? What is the relationship with the appraisal center? " Wang Le said that without this detail, they still have some confidence in the appraisal conclusion, but they doubt the impartiality of the appraisal institution.
Another "doubt" is that at the end of 10, Wang had a long talk with zhangyan's uncle for over an hour. The latter said that he had a large number of witnesses and physical evidence, and dozens of people could testify. Zhangyan had an unusual behavior the day before the incident. "His uncle said that zhangyan was abnormal at four o'clock-first, the day before the incident on June 16, zhangyan accidentally entered the men's toilet while studying in a foreign country, and was taken back to Linyi by his family that night 12; Second, on the morning of the incident, zhangyan sent her daughter to a table tennis match. After getting off the bus, she hugged her daughter three times. Third, when zhangyan sent her daughter to the competition, the driver was driving her car. When the driver returned, zhangyan began to chase his car. zhangyan went home to get his clothes, but he didn't take the front door. He practiced yoga on the wall and took off his shoes and threw them outside the courtyard. Fourth, when zhangyan went down the corridor before the incident, he threw his passbook outside. "
Wang believes that these explanations are too far-fetched to prove that zhangyan was insane before the incident. "Her performance is probably because she has a mistress with her husband and the couple are embarrassed." What makes Wang suspicious is that zhangyan's uncle had told him that a large amount of evidence had been accepted by the police before the appraisal conclusion came down. "I heard that zhangyan's uncle took these witnesses to the criminal police to testify. We think these testimonies are unfair. "
Regarding zhangyan's behavior, Wang insisted that the "mistress" problem triggered the marriage crisis, lost control of her emotions, retaliated against the society, and then pretended to be crazy to avoid responsibility.
Family of the perpetrator: Before the incident, she was ill and had been naked many times.
The reporter then interviewed zhangyan's second uncle Zhang Guoqiang (at the request of the interviewee, using a pseudonym), which was the first time that zhangyan's family appeared for media interviews since the incident.
Zhang Guoqiang told reporters that because zhangyan's father was paralyzed in bed, his mother couldn't bear the heavy blow, and her husband Liu Zhen had a craniotomy earlier, so he was introverted and inarticulate. So after zhangyan's accident, he has been in charge of related matters. "In addition to zhangyan's accident, it can be said that everything Wang Jiahe said in the media is false, including the mistress problem, the niece ran out because of the couple's fight that day, the son-in-law at the scene, and so on. These rumors are all false. The relationship between husband and wife is particularly good, and there is no such thing as a mistress. "
Zhang Guoqiang tone is very heavy, said the zhangs' harm to the wangs "family confession, should repent, must repent. After what happened, I said that my niece should bear any responsibility, but I can't accept how bad my child is. She is really a very good and excellent child. " As for why zhangyan has such abnormal behavior, Zhang Guoqiang thinks that the judicial appraisal report is an "ironclad case", and "out of control is out of control of mental disorder, not emotional disorder."
Regarding the family members' history of mental illness, Zhang Guoqiang revealed that zhangyan's aunt had mental disorder and her uncle committed suicide due to depression in his thirties. He believes that zhangyan's mental disorder may be caused by the pressure of long-term gathering in life and work. Zhangyan ranks third. There is a brother and a sister in the world. His father is hemiplegic and his brother-in-law has passed away. His sister has not come out of the shadows yet. "Zhang Yan has two children to take care of. My nephew Liu Zhen's only problem is that he doesn't care much about his family and is playful."
According to juwan's observation, zhangyan's spirit had been normal until June 20 12, although he was a little paranoid since he was a child.
On June 12, zhangyan went on a business trip to attend an increasingly active local "study class". In fact, the Zhang family members are not very clear about the situation of this class. They only heard that it is a large-scale public welfare organization, which cultivates people's healthy spirit of helping others and psychologically repairs the shortcomings of students. Zhangyan participated in this class through Zhang Zhiyuan, the kindergarten where his son is located. Before leaving, he reassured his mother that he had studied very well and talked with his family many times during his study. Everything is normal. However, on the last day of study, June 16, zhangyan suddenly turned out to be abnormal.
Zhang Guoqiang introduced that this afternoon, zhangyan suddenly giggled at the lecturer and imitated the students' movements. After class, he fought with someone in the ladies' room and then went to the men's room. "What's more, there is a setting in the course where everyone closes their eyes and listens to a song. When everyone closed their eyes, she suddenly undressed, and at least five students could testify. Do you think she is sane? ! "
After being informed by the students, the family members rushed to the location of the class overnight and took zhangyan back to Linyi. At that time, she was found abnormal and hugged her classmates and said, "I'm afraid!" " First, I refused to get on the bus. After getting on the bus, I didn't say anything. I took off my shoes and threw them in the car. "I have refused to wear shoes since I got sick." Liu Zhen was not at home at that time. zhangyan's mother was at home to help her take care of the children, but when she got home, zhangyan asked her to burn her notebook. "This notebook simply records the contents and methods of learning, inspirational slogans and so on. The most important thing is to leave a classmate's phone number. That's why I have these witnesses. " Zhang Guoqiang recalled.
Zhangyan stripped naked and lay on the ground again. At first, her mother thought she wanted to take a bath, but when she saw that her eyes were straight, she slapped her and asked her daughter if she had done anything bad. As a result, zhangyan returned to normal. "Mom, I'm sorry, I'm going to take a shower."
On the morning of June 12, 17, zhangyan sent his daughter to a table tennis match, which was driven by a friend. In the car, zhangyan suddenly gasped, and his friend was surprised, but zhangyan immediately explained: "Nothing, I am crazy about practicing yoga. Aren't you afraid?" After that, he took off his shoes and threw them into the co-pilot position, barefoot. After returning home, zhangyan's performance was abnormal. She sat on the fence in front of her mother-in-law's house for five or six minutes, talking to herself, and no one could hear clearly. She took off her shoes and went barefoot again. "Her mental illness is not fake, but persistent." Zhang Guoqiang explained that zhangyan walked barefoot from her mother-in-law's house and told her that everything in the house was fake, clamoring to throw it away. Her mother had no choice but to put these things in four bags, passbook, gold and silver jewelry, cosmetics and RMB. "She took my sister-in-law's hand and said, Mom, let's go, something will happen to our family. Catch up with the car in front! "
Mother thought that the couple had quarreled and Zhang Yan was going after Serina Liu. Unexpectedly, she was insane. When she went downstairs, zhangyan threw four bags out at once. Since then, witnesses have seen zhangyan pull open the doors of several cars parked in the community at will. "At that time, being understood by others as emotional out of control was actually insanity. As soon as he got on the bus, he slammed on the accelerator and entered the braking state. " Zhang Guoqiang thought that zhangyan could not have deliberately targeted Wang Yanli's mother and daughter.
After the tragedy, zhangyan pinched her mother's neck twice, and her neck turned purple. Fortunately, the security guard stopped it in time. According to her family, she explained in the transcript, "I didn't pinch my mother. A voice in my ear told me that my mother had a little demon and I was saving her."
Witnesses said that they had heard zhangyan say, "I am so angry!" And threatened to kill Xiaosan, and the second uncle said that he was not very clear about it. Juwan said that the outside world saw zhangyan naked to stop the rescue and catch the injured child through video. In fact, the video only recorded a fragment of the event. After that, she went naked to another family with whom she had a good personal relationship. The host of this family is at home, so it's embarrassing. He found clothes to help zhangyan wrap himself up and comfort her, but at this time, zhangyan jumped on the child and almost strangled him.
Investigation: the mysterious "study class"
After the accident, zhangyan was found to have no normal emotional reaction, and the Zhang family realized that zhangyan might be mentally ill. In the afternoon, they sent zhangyan to a local mental hospital in Linyi. At noon the next day, zhangyan was taken away by the police. The doctor wrote three items in the diagnosis and treatment book: emergency treatment, assisting the police to leave the hospital for investigation, and suggesting further systematic treatment. According to family members, after zhangyan was taken to the police station, she was relieved and told her family that it was fine here. The little devil couldn't get in and fell asleep.
Zhangyan was held in a detention center. For five months, her family has never seen her, and they don't know her mental state. They applied for medical treatment in zhangyan, but the police asked them to produce corresponding evidence. "We didn't hire a lawyer, we consulted, but the cost was prohibitive." Zhang's family is under great mental pressure. In the face of online criticism, Zhang chose silence and refused to accept any interview.
So, what kind of "study class" did zhangyan attend, what kind of experience and performance did she have there, and how did these relate to her acute transient mental illness? This has become the biggest mystery in Zhang's family.
According to the clues provided by the Zhang family, the reporter found that this "study class" was actually organized by a local enterprise management consulting company in Linyi. After consulting the company's website, the reporter found that its prominent position was "Introduction of Tutors", and click on the link to see "National Certification System arranges tutors, simple and rapid physical and mental active therapy executors, life growth coach ..." and other contents.
Zhang Yan wants to participate in the "Leadership Quality Training", and the leadership quality training course claims to improve the students' comprehensive quality and leadership ability through three stages of experience training: self-discovery, self-transcendence and personal and team goals. The duration of the course is 4 days and 3 nights in the first stage, 5 days and 4 nights in the second stage and 108 days in the third stage.
The reporter found a student who didn't want to be named and was in the same period as zhangyan. He revealed that Zhang Yan participated in the second stage of training, but the student refused to disclose the core information such as the content and method of training, only told reporters that Zhang Yan had been "not bubbling" in the process of "discovering himself" and "surpassing himself". The so-called "no bubbling" means that zhangyan doesn't open her heart like nearly 70 other students, and her tutor can't "connect" to enlighten her. Other students also tried to help her "open", but they all failed. As for the way to help, the student also refused to disclose.
During the training period, students sleep for a short time every day and don't sleep at all on the last night, which is also a course mode for similar training institutions in China to exercise their will. But he told reporters with certainty that there is no way to challenge the moral and legal bottom line in the process of discovering and surpassing oneself. 16 in the afternoon, zhangyan appeared a series of mental disorders, such as undressing, smirking and going into the men's room. The student witnessed it with his own eyes, but he thought that zhangyan's disorder had nothing to do with the study class, because everyone else had no problem and succeeded in "surpassing themselves".
Zhang Guoqiang also investigated the "study class" afterwards, and found that the organization did organize its members to carry out charitable activities in Linyi area many times, and some local leaders even participated in some activities. He wondered whether the training methods and inspirational methods of the class were overloaded, but unfortunately, all the students he came into contact with were secretive about it. "So many people say that they will become more determined after taking part in the research, and nothing has happened except zhangyan? I really can't explain it. "
On the afternoon of 201211kloc-0/9, Wang went to the public security organ in Linyi City to continue to ask for a complete appraisal report. The police mainly introduced zhangyan's participation in the "study class" before the incident, and planned to investigate the "study class".
Wang Le was very surprised when he first heard the news. He was even more surprised when the reporter introduced Zhang's above statement to him. That night, Wang found a friend who had studied in the "study class" through his relationship, and moved the other party through his sad statement. This friend thinks that zhangyan's undressing in the class is not an abnormal performance, because there is a content in the process of surpassing the class-undressing, and the tutor is a man and a woman, asking male and female students to do things that they dare not do at ordinary times, such as undressing, dancing, hugging and "communicating" with the tutor.
As for the specific contents of "openness" and "communication", the student was unwilling to disclose it, and suggested that Wang could sign up for the study himself if he was interested, but the registration had to go through strict qualification examination. During the study, the tutor would confiscate the student's mobile phone and was not allowed to take pictures or videos. "When learning enters the third stage, students will be asked to go to the streets to raise money. They will be asked to raise hundreds of thousands of yuan in a short time. After receiving 5 million, 3 million was used for charitable donations, and 2 million was reserved for management fees. " Wang thinks this organization is extremely mysterious and has great problems.
But Wang still insisted on going to an appraisal institution he trusted to re-evaluate whether zhangyan was really sick. "If really sick, I also want to find out what is the connection with this class? Who is responsible for this tragedy? "