According to media reports, a few days ago, the Qingdao Municipal Government promulgated the local regulations "Measures for the Administration of Primary and Secondary Schools in Qingdao" (hereinafter referred to as the "Measures").
Article 11 of this method stipulates that primary and secondary schools should give criticism and education or appropriate punishment to students who affect the order of education and teaching; If the circumstances are serious, be punished according to the circumstances; The rules of school discipline should be made public to students. This is the first time that the national and local education laws and regulations put forward the concept of "punishment".
The primary and secondary schools mentioned in the Measures have the right to "appropriately punish" students who affect the order of education and teaching, which has aroused heated discussion among netizens. Some people agree that it is not advisable to indulge children's education blindly, some people suggest that the degree of punishment is not well defined, and others worry that it may lead to corporal punishment in disguised form, making teachers afraid to exercise their right to criticize and punish.
Voice: Do you support the teacher's punishment when students make mistakes?
Is it appropriate to punish Xiong Haizi? How to grasp the degree of "appropriate sentencing" Let's hear what they have to say.
Viewpoint 1: There are no rules, and there is no Fiona Fang to help children correct their mistakes.
Ms. Wang lives in Jiangbei District, and her children are in the third grade of primary school. In Ms. Wang's view, it is appropriate for the school to take appropriate punishment for children who affect the normal teaching order. If a child makes a mistake and doesn't get the corresponding criticism and education, it is doting and conniving. On the contrary, under the proper disciplinary education of teachers, children will be helped to understand and correct their mistakes. "Without rules, there would be no Fiona Fang." Teacher Li, who has been teaching in a middle school in Shapingba District for many years, said that the Measures gave proofreaders the "disciplinary power", provided legal and regulatory support for teachers to criticize and educate students normally, and urged students to consciously abide by discipline.
Viewpoint 2: the punishment scale is not easy to grasp or has the opposite effect.
Mr. Zhou, who lives in Jinxiang Community in Shapingba District, said that the child is in middle school. He thinks that primary and secondary school students are very independent and precocious. If the scale of punishment is not well grasped, it may be counterproductive and easily lead to children's rebellious psychology.
expert opinion/advice
Nowadays, more and more parents don't recognize the disciplinary method of teachers standing and writing. "The reason for this situation is that parents' attitudes have changed and public opinion in society has also changed." Min Lu, a national second-level psychological counselor and a member of the expert group of Jinan Mental Health Guidance Center, analyzed that the first generation of only children had become parents and grew up in the era of "punishing students", and they had natural resistance to punishment.
Qian Wenzhong, a professor of history at Fudan University, once said in the Weibo that education for children is mostly encouragement, but education cannot be completed by encouragement alone, and education cannot be without disciplinary measures.
Experts say that blindly advocating encouraging education without punishment weakens students' ability to resist setbacks. Experts said that for the punishment of teachers, the first thing to be clear is that the teacher's original intention is good. Secondly, we should rationally grasp the "degree" of punishment. "We can sign contracts with students and choose ways that students can accept. Not only can students realize their mistakes and avoid making them again in the future, but it also has no influence on students. Therefore, it is not bad for teachers to punish students for making repeated mistakes. "
In this regard, many parents also believe that teachers can replace the role of parents in school. "Teachers should be punished for educating their children, otherwise, if teachers really let it go, it will be their own children who suffer."