A complete analysis of secrets that cannot be told.
Elementary chapter: full of loopholes?
First, how to travel through time and space?
"Time travel" here is a concept in the movie world view. Playing secrets according to certain rules can make a person go back to the past or reach the future (to other time and space). However, in other time and space, only the first person who sees the player knows the existence of the player.
Second, can you be seen after traveling through time and space?
The unspoken rule of time travel is that after time travel, the first person you see can see you.
Therefore, it is impossible for only Ye Xianglun to see Lu Xiaoyu, so there will be a plot in which Lu Xiaoyu talks with Qing and Da Yong runs away when he sees Lu Xiaoyu.
Third, are the time of the two time and space consistent?
The answer is yes. Lu Xiaoyu himself said that it was the same day in different years when he had just been here for 20 years.
Lu Xiaoyu's graduation ceremony through time and space also happens to be Ye Xianglun's graduation ceremony.
4. Why didn't Xiaoyu come 15 days?
Because I saw Ye Xianglun and Qingyi together at the football match, I was angry. Maybe I had an asthma attack. It also laid the groundwork for a series of events such as the misunderstanding of piano room and graduation ceremony.
This explains why Lu Xiaoyu walked with his eyes closed, how the note went to Qingyi, and how Dayong saw Kohane. It's not a loophole. The story is perfect. You can tell if you look closely.
5. How does Xiaoyu talk to Qingyi when playing the piano? The plot is wrong?
No, it can be seen from the plot that the first person who opens his eyes to see Xiaoyu after 20 years can see her. She wanted to open her eyes and see Xiang Lun, but what she saw was Qingyi, so Qingyi could see and talk to Xiaoyu, but Xiang Lun, who was playing the piano, didn't see the rain around Qingyi.
Intermediate: Happy ending?
1. Is Lu Xiaoyu dead?
Yes, the evidence is Xiaoyu's hair.
Careful friends will find that Lu Xiaoyu has not traveled through time and space for five months, and his hair is longer than when he first met Ye Xianglun. Graduation ceremony, Ye Xianglun's hug and Li's jokes are all long hair.
Ye Xianglun's light rain hair after traveling through time and space is short, not long!
And it's not graduation day, Lu Xiaoyu is doing his homework; And I don't seem to know Ye Xianglun. It should be said that I just don't know him.
Xiaoyu is indeed dead, and Xiaoyu who loves Ye Xianglun is also dead. To some extent, it is the biggest tragedy of this film.
Because Xiao Lun didn't attend the graduation ceremony of 1979. Suppose the graduation ceremony is on September 1 day, and Xiaoyu discovers that the piano score is on March 1 day. Xiao Lun may have gone back to February 1979, when nothing happened. And according to the word "parallel universe" in Baidu Encyclopedia, it shows that Xiao Lun may have returned to another space, and Xiaoyu in that space doesn't know Xiao Lun yet.
Second, where did Ye Xianglun go?
I call 99 time and space a and 79 time and space b.
Rain B in Time-Space B has a love affair with the item in Time-Space A. When all the items in Time-Space A want to travel through time-space, the item does not come to Time-Space B, but to Time-Space C and meets Xiao Yu C; Space-time c is before Xiaoyu discovers the secret score, and nothing has happened yet.
Third, how to explain graduation photo?
The unspoken rule of traveling through time and space is that only the person who sees you for the first time can see you. Graduation photo explained that everyone in space-time C can see Shannon A; The explanation is that the piano as a time-travel medium was destroyed, and Ye Xianglun couldn't go back. Allen, the item of time and space A, stays in time and space C forever, and the hidden rules are invalid.
4. Why did Ye Xianglun go to the third time and space?
The road to time and space, b Xiaoyu, b successfully came to time and space every time. How can Ye Xianglun of Time and Space A be misplaced?
There are two versions of the secret piano music on the soundtrack CD, one is the ordinary version of Lu Xiaoyu and the other is the accelerated version of Ye Xianglun. Ye Xianglun was in an emergency, so he popped up an accelerated version of the "secret" and returned to an earlier time and space C. Moreover, because Xiaoyu B and Xiaoyu C could not meet in one space, Xiaoyu B could not reach time and space C, and Xiao Lun in space C was not born yet, so it is possible for Xiao Lun A to reach time and space C.
5. How to change history?
The main text mentions the consistency of two different time and space, so what you do at an earlier time will change the history later.
Therefore, the final ending of this film is: the item of time and space A, Ahrenby time and space B, returned to time and space C early, which changed all the history of time and space B and A. ..
Advanced articles: the hidden secrets of history
You think you know all the secrets of this movie? Do you really understand the secret that you can't tell?
One, three, three light rains.
Xiaoyu b in time and space b died, and Xiaoyu c and Shannon a in time and space c lived happily together; What about the light rain in space-time A?
Light Rain C in Time and Space C Because Time and Space C is earlier than Time and Space B and Time and Space A, Xiao Lun changed the fate of Light Rain C in Time and Space C and kept it alive.
You may say that Xiao Yuqing in time and space B is dead, but where is Xiao Yuqing in time and space A?
Think carefully about the words that Xiaoyu carved on the table, which did not exist at first, but suddenly appeared, because Xiaoyu B in time and space changed;
Assuming there is no misunderstanding, Xiaoyu B will not be stimulated to have an asthma attack and die;
Time and space A's desk has no words until time and space B's light rain B doesn't write.
In the same way, before the light rain in B time and space B died, the light rain in A time and space did not die!
But the light rain A in space-time A is 1999, and the light rain A in 1979 is definitely not dead!
Secondly, the existence of light rain in 1999 space-time A proves that 1999 Xiaoyu's mother is not crazy.
Xiaoyu at this time should be a middle-aged man of about forty years old.
Xiaoyu B took incense to the roof of her house for the first time. Before going upstairs, a middle-aged woman was photographed watching Ye Xianglun go to the roof (she couldn't see Xiaoyu B either). That person is either Xiao Yu's mother or middle-aged Xiao Yu A.
The second time Xiaoyu B didn't go to class for many days. Xiang Lun went to Xiaoyu's house, met her mother and bought many apples. Of course, the apple is for Xiaoyu, not for Xiaoyu who died of madness.
Shannon went to Xiaoyu's house for the third time. Xiaoyu's mother said Xiaoyu was resting, and then she went into the house. At the same time, the camera cut to the second floor of Xiaoyu's house. Ye Xianglun's movements are consistent with those of Xiaoyu's mother when she first entered. The person watching on the second floor is not Xiaoyu's mother, but a middle-aged Xiaoyu.
Xiang Lun went to Xiaoyu's house for the fourth time and went in for the first time. It was also after Xiaoyu was found missing that Xiaoyu found the bracelet on Shannon's hand and died of grief.
Xiaoyu's mother let Xianglun into the room and said Xiaoyu was listening to music in the room. It is true that Xiao Yuqing A was listening to music in the room, but the corresponding Xiao Yuqing B died 20 years ago before Shannon entered the room. The history of time and space A changed because of the change of time and space B. At the same time, Xiang Lun found Xiao Yu's hand-painted portrait of Xiang Lun. Xiao Yu's mother cried and said, "Mom should believe Xiao Yu." At this time, Xiaoyu's mother was also changed by history, thinking that Xiaoyu was dead.
Before, Xiaoyu's mother always said Xiaoyu was there, not crazy; It did rain lightly before.
Third, the result analysis.
Time and space A Ye Xianglun's father lost his son, perhaps because he didn't keep Xiao Yu's secret, which is a tragedy;
Xiaoyu's mother lost her daughter in Time and Space Road B, because it was a tragedy for her daughter to read the piano score of Secret.
Xiao Yu, the road of time and space B, was not believed by everyone, even teased, tortured and died with endless grief, which is a tragedy;
Time and space A Ye Xianglun wanted to go to time and space B to find Lu Xiaoyu B who loved him, but there was no way to say goodbye, which became an eternal tragedy;
It's a tragedy that Dayong fell in love with Ye Xianglun by mistake because he believed Xiaoyu was fooled. ......
Finally, Allen, the item of time and space A, went to time and space C, which changed all the history of time and space B and time and space A, prevented all tragedies from happening, and became a perfect ending, which was also a more dramatic ending. (This is also the ending that the audience wants to see. )
Precautions:
Time and space: 99 years.
Time and space B: 79 years
Time and space C: C: Before Xiaoyu discovered the music score in 79.
There are three light rains ABC and one Shannon A corresponding to three time and space; In 79, there was no Shannon in B and C time and space, and there was no birth.
* Multi-temporal theory: Our space is divided into countless parts by time; Special forces can shuttle through it.
Likebai: also known as "correction fluid" and "correction fluid"
Fourth, the supplement of historical synchronous changes (a secret that I don't want to tell)
Like traveling through time and space, the film brings the same unexplained phenomenon, and history changes synchronously.
It is clear to all that the words on the table suddenly appeared in the Li incident; This phenomenon has never appeared in real life, at least it has not been confirmed.
The reason why it suddenly appears on the table is because someone in time and space B has changed history, so things in time and space after time and space B have changed accordingly. However, due to the coexistence of multiple time and space, it seems that something is suddenly added or lost in the changing time and space.
So there will be things like words suddenly appearing on the table, people suddenly disappearing from history, and people's memories suddenly being modified. ......
Xiao Yuqing A and B both fell in love with Xiao Lun at the same time, experienced misunderstanding at the same time, and disappeared from history at the same time, only 20 years apart; It's just that all this is the experience of Xiao Yu B, and Xiao Yu A is only passively changing synchronously and has the same experience. In fact, Xiao Yu's feelings had no direct connection with Xiao Lun, but were constantly changed by history and finally disappeared.
In fact, this is just a movie, a fantastic plot; In real life, at present, mankind has not proved a feasible plan to travel through time and space; There has never been a historical synchronous change, and even if there is, it is impossible to know. Perhaps it is "Einstein's theory of relativity itself is a fallacy", or it may be that human science and technology have not developed to that point. In any case, this is just a fictional movie plot.
I hope you can understand the above, even if you don't understand, don't continue to ask questions. This is a fictional film in itself, not real life.
Five, boring corner
Some people will say that Taiwan Province Province was not established in 1979. That is the reality. This is a movie.
Some people will say that Ye Xianglun went back to the past and changed all history. Doesn't he have two selves? God will arrange someone else to be Huang Qiusheng's son.
Xiao Lun spoke into the air, and no one noticed? Others can't see Xiao Yu, and naturally they can't hear what Xiao Yu said. This question is really "good" If you are talking, the opposite person can only see you open your mouth, but can't hear your voice, which only shows that you are not normal.
Xiao Lun didn't ask anyone about Xiaoyu, so she found that there was no such person.
Dayong wasn't beaten silly, was he? What is that? Do you want to ask him through time and space?
I can give the obsessed person a satisfactory ending: Xiao Lun is a patient in a mental hospital, and it turns out that all this is just his fantasy.
I can give a satisfactory ending to those who don't want to think about it: 20 years later, Xiao Lun came back and lived happily with Xiaoyu.
It's time for everyone to get back to reality. This is just a movie.
I want to say it myself: I began to regret it after writing the whole article. This is originally a "secret that cannot be told" and should not be written; In fact, it is enough to move everyone.
Say to the author of the last paragraph: In fact, if you hadn't written these, no one would have read them many times to find the answer, and also helped many people answer questions they still don't understand, so thank you! I know this is not the place to post, so I'm sorry, I just don't know what else to tell the author.
Sixth, the central idea of this film.
History can't change what happens in the real world. In fact, the meaning of Jay Chou's film is:
Cherish all the best things around you, including love and affection.
I hope my personal summary and some information will help Lanzhou. Please read it patiently.