Is Nanhai Law a Black Journal?

No, according to official website, the legal information of law in Peking University and Nanhai was added to the database of "Peking University Magic Weapon" law journals on April, 2023 10. Nanhai Law is an academic journal of law in Hainan Province approved by the State Administration of Press, Publication, Radio, Film and Television, with a high level and strict review process. Black journals refer to the low level of papers, perfunctory evaluation process or high edition fees. So Nanhai law is not a black publication.