Who is more suitable to be a monitor, Liu Bei or Cao Cao (debate)

Debate speech

Positive view: We think Liu Bei is more suitable to be a monitor. Liu Bei knows how to win people's hearts better than Cao Cao. Therefore, Zhao Zilong single-handedly saved Dou, while Liu Bei loved Jiang and threw anger at Dou, showing that Liu Bei was good at winning people's hearts. Being a monitor requires Liu Bei to be good at employing people and buying people's hearts. At this point, Liu Bei is more suitable to be a monitor, while Cao Cao is more arrogant, so-called arrogant.

Generally speaking, we think Liu Bei is more suitable to be a monitor. Because Liu Bei's personality is patient and tenacious, he has full affinity, which is very important in management. Example: Guan Yu rode thousands of miles alone, which is a great trust and profound friendship for Liu Bei. Liu Bei also has a famous saying: "Don't do it because of evil, don't do it because of good." This shows his carefulness. And his coordination ability is unintentional. Isn't this enough to show that Liu Bei is suitable to be a monitor?

Opposing party: On the contrary, it is inappropriate to give the position of monitor Cao Cao. Because Cao Cao is a king, such people will not be willing to belong to others, but will only clear away all obstacles that hinder his great cause by any means. Because there are many teachers above the rank of monitor, in this case, if individual teachers' instructions make him dissatisfied in all aspects of daily class management, I believe such people will even deal with teachers or sow discord among teachers. It is not surprising that students are even incited by their own positions to deal with teachers. Anyway, such people will try their best to repair their honor once they are beaten to nothing because they will not give in to others. Cao Cao became king because of his temperament and ability, so it is difficult to suppress such people and not let anyone step on them, otherwise it would not be Cao. Therefore, it is a waste to give only one shift to such people.

Liu Bei is really unfit to be the supreme leader, but the monitor of a class is not the supreme leader either. The monitor's duty is only to assist the teacher to handle the daily affairs of the class, implement the rules and regulations of the class, and perform the management tasks assigned by the teacher. In fact, the monitor is only a pupil, and it is not a good thing to be king. On the contrary, the monitor should learn from Liu Bei about his righteousness and orthodoxy, and take good care of all the students, who are studying. Unlike adults who have stepped into the society, we can't use military law to deal with the daily behavior of all students and the bad style in the class. On the contrary, we need to guide people to learn to be good under the guidance of the mode of benevolence and righteousness education. We can't always make the students who make mistakes angry to death!